Donald Trump Jr. is an adviser to BOTH Kalshi and Polymarket, btw
(this is deeply weird for all of the many reasons having Don Jr. as an adviser is deeply weird, AND also because the companies are the two major competitors in the prediction markets space)
They aren't perfect, but there is research to support their relative accuracy.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prediction_market#Accuracy
It makes sense, when you consider the concept of "ensemble learning" from machine learning. Errors and biases tend to average out.
@avery @rubinjoni @molly0xfff Yeah, there's also the consideration that making it about gambling, as opposed to using a very specific structure for the question, doesn't seem to improve accuracy. There are other ways to get people to be accurate, in other words. Gambling is more of a motive to participate than an actual source of accuracy, I think.
My personal interest in it isn't in the gambling side of it so much as the adaptation of machine learning techniques to effectively coordinate human decision making. I think it's a fun idea.