IsaacJul 27, 2025
@caseyliss as an Indianapolis lad I never ever thought I’d have the chance to finally try John’s but some stars aligned this weekend for me to hop over to New York and after listening to ATP for this long I had only one non-negotiable. Absolutely wonderful, 10/10 maybe my favorite thing I’ve ever eaten.
Show threadGabe Hannan
@ivining Fellow Indianapolis lad here. Have you ever had Brooklyn Char in Noblesville? I haven’t, but have heard good things and wondered how it might compare to John’s.
Jul 27, 2025 at 5:13pmIvory for iOS
Show threadIsaacJul 27, 2025
@gabehannan Sure have! This is my first time having any NYC pizza so I have very limited experience but I’d say Brooklyn Char’s style is fairly different to John’s. I had two other more “traditional” NYC style pies and I’d say BC is closer to those. Big Brooklyn Char fan!