TheMightyCat

Very large amounts of gaming gpus vs AI gpus

https://ani.social/post/16779906

Very large amounts of gaming gpus vs AI gpus - ani.social

cross-posted from: https://ani.social/post/16779655 [https://ani.social/post/16779655] > | GPU | VRAM | Price (€) | Bandwidth (TB/s) | TFLOP16 | €/GB | €/TB/s | €/TFLOP16 | > |-----------------------------|-------|-----------|------------------|---------------|------|---------|--------------| > | NVIDIA H200 NVL | 141GB | 36284 | 4.89 | 1671 | 257 | 7423 | 21 | > | NVIDIA RTX PRO 6000 Blackwell | 96GB | 8450 | 1.79 | 126.0 | 88 | 4720 | 67 | > | NVIDIA RTX 5090 | 32GB | 2299 | 1.79 | 104.8 | 71 | 1284 | 22 | > | AMD RADEON 9070XT | 16GB | 665 | 0.6446 | 97.32 | 41 | 1031 | 7 | > | AMD RADEON 9070 | 16GB | 619 | 0.6446 | 72.25 | 38 | 960 | 8.5 | > | AMD RADEON 9060XT | 16GB | 382 | 0.3223 | 51.28 | 23 | 1186 | 7.45 | > > This post is part “hear me out” and part asking for advice. > > Looking at the table above AI gpus are a pure scam, and it would make much more sense to (atleast looking at this) to use gaming gpus instead, either trough a frankenstein of pcie switches or high bandwith network. > > so my question is if somebody has build a similar setup and what their experience has been. And what the expected overhead performance hit is and if it can be made up for by having just way more raw peformance for the same price.

Jul 14, 2025 at 8:17pmWeb
Show threadhendrikJul 14, 2025

Well, I wouldn't call them a "scam". They're meant for a different use-case. In a datacenter, you also have to pay for rack space and all the servers which accomodate all the GPUs and you can now pay for 32 times as many servers with Radeon 9060XT or you buy H200 cards. That saves on the amount of servers and everything that comes with it, hardware cost, space, electricity, air-con, maintenance... Less interconnect makes everything way faster...

Of course at home different rules apply. And it depends a bit how many cards you want to run, what kind of workload you have... If you're fine with AMD or you need Cuda...

Show threadTheMightyCatJul 14, 2025

Yeah i should have specified for at home when saying its a scam, i honestly doubt the companies that are buying thousands of B200s for datacenters are even looking at their pricetags lmao.

Anyway the end goal is to run something like Qwen3-235B at fp8, with some very rough napkin math 300GB vram with the cheapest option the 9060XT comes down at €7126 with 18 cards, which is very affordable. But ofcourse that this is theoretically possible does not mean it will actually work in practice, which is what im curious about.

The inference engine im using vLLM supports ROCm so CUDA should not be strictly required.

Show threadhendrikJul 14, 2025

I think there are some posts out there (on the internet / Reddit / ...) with people building crazy rigs with old 3090s or something. I don't have any experience with that. If I were to run such a large model, I'd use a quantized version and rent a cloud server for that.

And I don't think computers can fit infinitely many GPUs. I don't know the number, let's say it's 4. So you need to buy 5 computers to fit your 18 cards. So add a few thousand dollars.

I can't make any statement for performance. I'd imagine such a scenario might work for MoE models with appropriate design. And for the rest performance is abysmal. But that's only my speculation. We'd need to find people who did this.

Show threadWombleJul 15, 2025
Theres also the upcomming Framework desktops with 128GB of unified ram for ~$2500
Configure Framework Desktop DIY Edition (AMD Ryzen™ AI Max 300 Series)

Choose from AMD and Intel system options, select your preferred memory and storage, operating system, and more customizations. Available in DIY and pre-built configurations.

Framework
Show threadbrucethemooseJul 15, 2025

They are a scam.

But:

  • Using gaming GPUs in datacenters is in breach of Nvidia’s license for the GPU.

…So, yes, they are a scam. But:

  • Datacenter is all about batched LLM performance, as the vram pools are bigger than models. In reality, one can get better parallel token/s on an H100 than you can on 2x RTX Pros or a few 5090s, especially with bigger models that take advantage of NVLink.
Show threadDisasterJul 15, 2025
I figured most datacenter customers wouldn’t be running pcie cards, they’d be running OAM for higher density.
Show threadZombiFrancisJul 15, 2025

I spent chunks of 2023 and 2024 investigating and testing image gen models after a cryptobro coworker kept talking about it.

I rigged up an old system and ran it locally to see wtf these things are doing. Honestly producing slop at 5 seconds per image v 5 minutes is meaningless in terms of value if 0% of the slop can be salvaged. And still, a human has to figure out what to so with the best candidates.

In fact at a certain speed it begins to work against itself as no one can realistically analyze AI gen output as fast as it is produced.

Conclusion: AI is mostly worthless. It just forces you to accept that human effort is the only thing with intrinsic value. And it’s as tough to get out of AI as it is to put any in.

And that’s looking past all the other gargantuan problems with AI models.

Show threadhumanspiralAug 8, 2025
for amd there is 7900xt at 20gb, and 7900xtx at 24gb. 4090 and 3090 are 24gb. The AMD ones might have similar $/gb and $/tflop as 9070xt.