I've been meaning to write this post for ages, but today's the day. Happy International Nonbinary People's Day! ๐Ÿ–ค๐Ÿ’œ๐Ÿค๐Ÿ’›

What is it like for me to be a nonbinary person?

When I was born, I was assigned male gender, presumably due to the mere fact that there was no vulva between my legs.

One aspect of my nonbinary experience is that there is nothing that I would like to change about my body. As I said, there was no vulva, but I never wanted one, so no harm done. I don't like the idea of having my body modified (I'm not even into piercings or tattoos). I don't love everything about my body, but I don't think that any medication or surgery could cure that. It's what they call a male body (i.e., I didn't give birth to our child nor breastfed them), but there's nothing male about it. A penis has no gender.

Due to the fact that I have hardly any body dysphoria, I'm not sure if I would call myself trans. I feel honoured if others see me as part of the trans community, but I am happy to acknowledge that my experience is different from that of (other) trans people.

The fact that my body is conspicuously similar to that of many men doesn't subtract from my nonbinarity in the least. There is nothing embarrassing about the fact that I'm both nonbinary and that my body is not. To me, being nonbinary is a social thing. We're talking gender, not sex.

If you see me as male, you're about as wrong as the people who think that I'm Portuguese. (People sometimes think that because I'm not too tall and have dark hair ๐Ÿคจ) There is nothing inherently offensive about being male (or Portuguese), but I'm just not. But I'm not a woman either and never wanted to be(come) one.

When I discovered in my youth that (some) men are hot, I initially assumed that I was gay and attributed my failure to be a 'proper' man to that fact. As it turns out, (some) women and nonbinary people are hot, too, so I'm not gay. I'm pansexual (I guess). I may have been aware of the concept of bisexuality in my youth, but I was unaware that one gets to be nonbinary if one wants.

In my teens, I thought that I was doing masculinity wrong. Now I've decided that I'm not doing it at all.

I usually feel uncomfortable among cishet men, much less so among cishet women (and even less so among queer people of any flavour), but as I said, I always knew that I never wanted to be a woman myself. I actively avoid all-male groups. With individual men, I decide on a case-by-case basis. Due to the fact that I appear to be male, nothing stops them from making incorrect assumptions and trying to make me part of their boys' club, and I'm just not having that. The whole gender binary makes no sense to me, but masculinity is the part that makes least sense to me, probably because that's the part that has been foisted on me for decades.

While I won't change anything about my body, I might change my presentation in the future, integrating any elements irrespective of their traditional association with one binary gender. I won't do this anytime soon for three reasons: First, I don't see it as necessary; I don't owe it to anyone to look like a nonbinary stock photograph. Second, I'm not sure if I could handle potentially negative feedback. Third, I'm constantly pressed for time. (I'm a parent, our toddler is three years old.)

In terms of pronouns, they/them is just fine in English. I live in Germany, so German plays some role in my daily life. In German, there is no nonbinary pronoun that is as common as they/them is in English. I prefer no pronouns in languages that don't have an established third option. (Maybe that's a bit harebrained because how will a third option ever become established if people don't use it before it is? ๐Ÿ˜)

In many contexts (especially the ones where I'm not out, e.g. at work), I'm referred to as he/him. As long as people treat me like a human being rather than a male human being, I'm not too offended by 'incorrect' pronouns. Assumptions matter more to me than pronouns โ€“ but it's lovely if you get them right.

So that's roughly what it's like for me to be a mid-30s nonbinary parent in Europe. Thanks for coming to my TED talk ๐Ÿ˜

Feel free to share if you liked it. Any questions? Fire away!

And once more: Happy International Nonbinary People's Day! ๐Ÿ–ค๐Ÿ’œ๐Ÿค๐Ÿ’›

#InternationalNonBinaryPeoplesDay #Nonbinary #NonbinaryPride

@SaySimonSay actually, I do have a question. Has becoming a parent changed your view of gender roles in general or your gender role specifically?

Myself, becoming a parent made me question gender stereotypes furiously and angrily, while before I was pretty relaxed, more like "meh, I just don't behave as female as I look, but I don't care what people think about that".

What was it like for you?

@lizzard Good question!

My awakening as a nonbinary person happened around the same time when I started being a parent. And I think that my experience was similar to yours: Before I became a parent, I was bewildered but not hugely offended by the whole gender song and dance. There's weirder stuff that adults inflict upon themselves.

Only when our child was born, I realised that this is an indoctrination that starts on day one. And it's presented with the greatest nonchalance that one could imagine: 'Oh that's just the way kids with a penis/vulva are' (sure, if you teach them that this is the only right way and chide them for being different).

My parents even did pretty okay in this respect. Both were intellectuals who 'just' wanted me to be clever and successful. This is extremely exhausting, too (and of course I failed) โ€“ but it was a gender-neutral requirement. My parents made me feel bad in various ways, but they didn't make me feel inadequate with respect to gender. The rest of the world took care of that.

@SaySimonSay fully agree, except - the gender stereotyping actually starts before day one, while the baby is still in utero.

I think one is also gendered more forcibly as a parent. It's extreme if one is pregnant, but even if that's not the case, there's a gendered role to fulfill and people make gendered assumptions.

It can make one more acutely aware of not feeling one's assigned gender for sure.

@lizzard

@quidcumque You said that you had some dysphoria โ€“ and that makes a lot of sense to me. People think that giving birth to a child and breastfeeding them etc. is the most 'female' thing that you can do. I disagree โ€“ it's one of the most bodily things that you can do if you have a body that offers those features. But I can very well imagine that it hurts when people feel even more inclined to make incorrect assumptions about your gender in a parenting context and even think that you'll love that.

I think that it's just cool to have a body that has certain features. You have randomly received model A that does the pregnancy and breastfeeding thing (which is extremely badass, though certainly exhausting). Others have randomly received model B that doesn't have the pregnancy module but can do other things. But that's completely unrelated to how you feel about gender.

I hope that you can look back at the things that your model A can do as experiences that are deeply bodily, but also deeply agender.

@lizzard

@SaySimonSay actually being pregnant, and then breastfeeding, *reduced* the dysphoria for me. I found it very cool that my body can grow and give birth to a human! I've always felt dysphoria with regards to the breasts, even before I knew a word for it, but putting them to a good use made me appreciate them in a new way.

But the language around pregnancy and childbirth is so gendered it *hurt*. I'd never been forcibly gendered like that, and it felt *wrong*.

@lizzard

@quidcumque @SaySimonSay meh, I have received a model with a significant amount of breasts that usually don't get ignored, yet they didn't do the milk thing. Didn't really help with loving my body, though luckily I appreciate it for other qualities, too. But, yeah, they turned out to be pretty useless (and heavy, and impractical!) decoration that I could do without. Still firmly in the "not changing anything about it" camp, though.

The experience of going through pregnancy is indeed very bodily. It's also extremely individual. I've not until now met two birth-givers whose experiences of pregnancy, birth and parenting were "pretty much the same".

@lizzard yes, I didn't mean that as a universal experience. I was pretty surprised that pregnancy wasn't total body horror (there is something GROWING inside me!!!) and breastfeeding wasn't total sensory overload (there's someone CLINGING to me ALL THE TIME!!!). Even giving birth was cool. I'm glad and thankful I got to experience that.

But that's my experience and others are radically different.

@SaySimonSay

@SaySimonSay thank you for sharing. So much THIS (doing gender wrong and having no words for it except "gay". Body parts have no gender. Feeling somewhat outside the cis-trans binary (๐Ÿ˜). Wanting to be treated as a human, not a gender. ALL THIS.)!!! ๐Ÿ–ค๐Ÿ’œ๐Ÿค๐Ÿ’›

(I do have some dysphoria, and being forcibly gendered feels worse than people making assumptions about my ancestry though.)

@quidcumque Thank you so much! Lots of nonbinary love ๐Ÿ–ค๐Ÿ’œ๐Ÿค๐Ÿ’›

(Yeah, agree, maybe I shouldn't have brought this in. It's a different thing.)

@SaySimonSay no, I think it's an interesting comparison, because it happens to me too. One of my great-grandparents immigrated from Greece, and because genetics is a lottery, my brother is blonde and blue-eyed and I'm sometimes given the "where are you from? No, where are you really from?" routine.

That annoys me, of course, and it's wrong because I just identify as a German (well, European first, German second, but whatever) but not as much as being forcibly gendered.

@SaySimonSay
People just used to always say they thought I was gay when I was younger, never been attracted to men. Just non-binary. I haven't really changed my body or appearance, but I wonder how much I would if I was out to my parents. Reading this I am so similar on so many points and really appreciate you posting this!
@SaySimonSay
๐Ÿ–ค๐Ÿ’œ๐Ÿค๐Ÿ’›

@SaySimonSay
Very well put! I've described myself in many of the same terms, except I'm ace as well. However, I genuinely don't find my body to be all that appalling - though I am considering some (minor) surgical solutions to sensory issues.

I simply don't get the whole "gender" thing at all, so trying to play-act conformance to the predefined roles seems... Well, pointless, really. Not to mention, it's exhausting.