@adam @dave @podcastguru @algrid

Just saw that the PodcastGuru Beta has Strike integration now.

Connected with no problem but only 3 splits (strike) were paid to PC 2.0.

Also the Strike logo is hard to see in the setting (3rd pic) in dark mode.

@ChadF @adam @dave @podcastguru Hopefully more podcasters will switch to lnaddress (Strike doesn't support keysend).
@algrid @ChadF @adam @dave @podcastguru sorry if these are dumb questions 😅 but I'm trying to understand the vision. how would boostagrams work? How would a podcaster switch to and get LNaddress? Guessing you'd need a whole new system for a helipad type thing too?
@sirtjthewrathful @algrid @ChadF @adam @dave Not dumb questions at all, AFAIK Alby and Strike both support lnaddress and if you have an Alby account you should already have one, but Strike doesn't support keysend. This just just gives people more options. @algrid correct me if I'm wrong? As far as helipad is concerned, I'm not sure if any changes are required.

@podcastguru @sirtjthewrathful @algrid @ChadF @adam @dave

From what I understand Helipad only relays boostagram info received from the tlv record (keysend). So any lnAddress boostagram would not show up.

lnAddress only supports 200ish characters of metadata which makes boostagrams very small. A different messaging system would need to be employed to relay TLV data. I believe Fountain is using Nostr for this.

AFAIK there is no agreed upon way of supporting full BGs with lnAddress.

@Kolomona @podcastguru @sirtjthewrathful @algrid @adam @dave

a lot of us want to figure this stuff out but its not really going anywhere sadly. :(

good news being able to pay from a wallet that only does lnadress/lnurl (dont know the difference) is very helpful for test.

@ericpp Does helipad plan to accept/log/show lnAddress payments?

I don't see an easy solution since you need a web server to negotiate & generate invoices on the fly.

Without feed, episode, & play timestamp (at least) in the payment message, it can't be linked to a podcast/episode/vts.

IPFS Podcasting also needs this info to distribute to the proper IPFS nodes. Without this info, it's just "I got sats".

@Kolomona @podcastguru @sirtjthewrathful @algrid @ChadF @adam @dave

@cameron It will once we figure out how to deal with the metadata problem in bolt11.

@merryoscar proposed Podpay https://podpay.org/ , but it got shot down because Nostr. Now he's using the funding tag to somehow capture the metadata.

Alecks Gates suggested a metaBoost tag (HTTP endpoint): https://github.com/Podcastindex-org/podcast-namespace/discussions/676

@StevenB built the The Split Box to split payments and store metadata: https://github.com/thebells1111/thesplitbox

@russell built a custom lnurl server and his own Helipad: https://github.com/podtoo/boostagramLIVE

Pod Pay

@cameron All of these options require the apps to adopt them.

I think we're headed into a very fragmented direction unless it gets figured out.

@ericpp @cameron

and those of us that are bought into lightning just keep using our own nodes with AlbyHub, Helipad and what ever apps support sending with Alby.

@ChadF @cameron Yep. Helipad will keep working fine with keysend payments.

You can have an LnAddress that points to a keysend address rather than lnurl. e.g. https://getalby.com/.well-known/keysend/ericpp

I think that would be the best option for self-hosters. It's just people using wallets that aren't Alby or Fountain that have to deal with this.

@ericpp I agree. TLV was a nice solution.

Sending, storing, & retrieving metadata via various methods & protocols feels "kuldgy".

Was considering a separate address/wallet for every incoming podcast/split, but that also feels messy, and doesn't solve the episode/VTS needs.

I don't have any "good" ideas. : (

@cameron Keysend is great because you don't need any additional infrastructure besides a Lightning node.

LnAddress on its own requires an HTTP server, which I think most podcasters have.

Lnurl requires an HTTP server application that can talk to your node.

Metadata requires an application and a database.

I liked Podpay the best out of the options because it's easy to integrate and to run a relay. Others didn't like it because of the Nostr social network and no privacy of metadata.

@ericpp @cameron

One cool thing I think we could do with Nostr is make Boost(agrams) way more visible. Just post to the major relays but I think that might get rate limited.

You could also just run your own relay so its all private or run a relay that you let other shows post to so its kind of like we have here but with Boost data.

I have chadf.nostr1.com and it cost 7k sats a month. I have it whitelisted so only certain people can post to it but anyone can read from it.

nostr1.com

@ChadF @cameron Yep. You can run your own relay or share a relay with others. It's just a dumb content store and it doesn't matter which one you use because they all work the same.

Privacy can also be handled through encryption, which is how private messages are kept private on Nostr.