So my thoughts on SpaceX's latest failure...

From an engineering standpoint I'm wondering what forces on the upper stage have caused these failures. Is there a lack of vibration dampening? Is the upper stage just too fragile or is it suffering a manufacturing defect when being mated to the 1st stage? Is the hot staging causing damage? A number of ideas run through my brain.

As a leftist seeing a fash company's rocket crash out is satisfying tho. Even if it means certain delays in space faring progress for the US.

@ClaireFelidae Politics aside...

The booster teams got valuable data out of the higher angle of attack. I do feel the ship teams have had a blow to their morale because of the radical redesign not panning out.

@JackRacc My concern is largely that of the "go fast and break things" approach may have worked within proven design envelopes like dragon was operating in but doesn't at the edge of material science we are operating at.

The sheer waste of relearning lessons the hard way rather than taking a more methodical design process with in-lab testing of the upper stage under similar physical loading conditions is managerial and engineering malpractice.

This is best demonstrated by early failures because SpaceX didn't want to use a vibration arresting water system like similar vehicles have used for years to disastrous effect. This is not a lesson they needed to learn the hard way and the homework was already done.

This shows a complete disdain for work and education of the experts in this field that typifies the ideology of Musk in a nutshell both politically and in terms of design rigor. His mental far right crash out is effecting his leadership.

@ClaireFelidae The part I agree with is rushing causes disaster. The Fondag on Flight 1 was not enough and honestly the deluge plate should have been installed in the first place.

and unfortunately with "just send it" still as a mentality being pushed, there is going to be a PR disaster incoming.

Wasting an "obsolete" block of ship as the excuse to send it is something pretty much no one will agree is a sane way to test.