UPDATE: I haven't seen Recall in action there. I was just asking the doctor how they'll deal with it.

This morning, I went to the doctor for a scheduled appointment. While she was looking at the results of blood tests from two years ago on the screen (and suggested repeating them for a follow-up), I realized she was using Windows 11. A detail came to mind. The doctor is extremely polite and friendly, so I asked her, "How do you handle the feature called Recall?" The doctor was taken aback and had no idea what I was talking about. I was about to drop the conversation, but she, being a serious professional, immediately called the technicians who manage their PCs to ask for clarification. They downplayed it, saying it's not an issue and that it's a feature "on all PCs, so we can't do anything about it." She started to express that she didn’t like it and wanted it deactivated. No luck: they won’t proceed because, according to them, even deactivating it is "a hack that could compromise future updates." She’s furious and will talk to her colleagues and the decision-makers. She wants secure systems because "there’s patient data involved."

In reality, patient data is stored on servers (which I haven't investigated), but everything that appears on the screen is, in my opinion, at risk.

I’ve offered to help them find a solution—because, if I'm right, all they need is LibreOffice and a browser. In that case, I’ll suggest one of the *BSD or Linux systems and do it for free.

I don’t want to make money off my doctor. I just want patient data to be (sufficiently) secure.

#IT #Recall #Windows #OwnYourData #Security #Privacy #RunBSD #Linux

@stefano the little I read about Recall, it shouldn't be active by default on every device with win11, but only on specific ones. I may be wrong about this.
@bovaz @stefano If I remember correctly, it requires an ai "coprocessor" (NPU). https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/copilot-plus-pcs which microsoft markets as "Copilot+" computers. Usually I'd downplay this (because most of the clients I work with purchase through dell, lenovo and so on never Microsoft) but considering the context... yeah I could see doctors wanting a surface or similar device. It also seems that they expanded it from Microsoft computers to other vendors https://www.dell.com/en-us/lp/copilotpc.
Shop Copilot+ PCs: Windows AI PCs and Laptop Devices | Microsoft Windows

Shop Copilot+ PCs, the fastest, most intelligent Windows PCs ever. Explore Windows AI tools and features built into the latest PCs, desktops, and laptop devices.

Windows