An important thing about Elon Musk that’s widely known in tech circles but perhaps not in the wider world: he’s an ignoramus.

His technical knowledge is shallow and careless, full of parroting and fantasizing.

People who’ve worked on the small amount of code he actually wrote long ago describe his work as an unskilled mess.

At every company he runs, there are teams of people devoted to keeping him away from the engineers, who largely succeed to the extent that he forgets they exist.

1/3

Musk does have a special talent, but the talent is for hype: projecting the kind of overconfidence that gets investors who also have shallow technical understanding to give him money.

That kind of overconfidence •requires• ignorance. Any actual understanding of technical details might give him a dangerous sense of nuance and complexity, which of course would scare away investors looking for an infallible Supergenius Unicorn who can offer huge returns.

He's basically P. T. Barnum.

2/3

One of my students remarked the other day that Musk seemed like a supervillain straight out of a comic book — and I agree. Sort of Lex Luthor but a dumbass.

This piece you gives interesting dimension to that observation: charismatic incompetence can be appealing as a destructive force when people don’t believe the status quo is worth saving.

https://www.nytimes.com/2024/11/23/books/review/supervillains-joker-elon-musk-wicked.html?smid=nytcore-ios-share&referringSource=articleShare

3/3

From ‘Wicked’ to Elon Musk, How Americans Learned to Root for the Supervillain

How Americans learned to root for the dark side — from the Joker and “Wicked” to Elon Musk.

The New York Times

And I guess I need to close the obvious-but-needs-stating loop on that:

This nihilistic desire for destruction is how fascism gets in the door.

4/3

@inthehands I honestly don’t get the “projecting confidence“ part. He already had that mystique first time I saw him keynote a Tesla event and I couldn’t watch all that yammering and halting speech. It was messy and made him seem unprepared and neglectful of his audience. And the audience eating it all up and new-clothesing it made it that much grosser.
@godofbiscuits @inthehands I am generally not all that fond of Dead Ringers' caricatures of Americans, but they portray Musk as a robot and I think that does capture something essential about him that their portrayals of Trump, Biden, and Harris largely fail to do. (Of course they are performing for a British audience that may not be well attuned to the niceties of #uspol but is very accustomed to fakers and bullies.)