In hindsight I should have chosen the Vegan Leather, it may look worn after a year, but at least the water resistance would be mostly intact.
But another thing is, it probably wouldn’t even have slipped out of my pocket, the glass was simply too slippery, which is why it dropped out.
Now I have the sleeve on that came with the phone, and it clearly is much more safe in my pocket, because it’s not nearly as slippery.