One of the most insane things about GDPR today are the banners that split cookies by purpose and then allow you to toggle consent and legitimate interest for each.

This makes zero sense! A toggle is literally consent. A company's legitimate interest is something they have, not something I can consent to! This is just a ridiculous way to add way too many toggles to be practical to untick

@Techaltar
It's bonkers, yup.
But this is the way they are "disclosing" to you that there's much more information they gather that goes over and above what they would call "legitimate interest".
They just make the "no to everything/reject all" to be more obtuse, so you don't want to go through it next time.

@Techaltar

Is this really insane about the GDPR though? My experience is that companies go out of their way to make their GDPR compliance as malicious as possible, hoping that people will blame the law, not the shady practices of the company. They did the same with the cookie banners as well, and were very successful on that front.

@ainmosni I'm no lawyer, but I read the GDPR rules for my video that I did on it and legitimate interest was written in a deliberately vague way in my opinion specifically to create a large gray zone.
Also, I see this specific tool being used by many reputable sites in the exact same configuration, so I have to assume that some lawyers decided this could technically be considered GDPR compliant.
If I'm right, then I think I do have GDPR to blame for not making rules clearer

@Techaltar I agree on the vagueness of the rules, the way that I, and legal, read that part, when the GDPR was coming in (I worked at a place where it was a very big thing) was that legitimate interest didn't need consent at all but that legitimate interest was very narrow.

Of course those memories are now quite far away as I haven't been focused on it since I left that company.

I think we can blame both the GDPR for being too vague, and the companies for their malicious compliance.

@Techaltar many cookie pop-up are misinterpretations of the gdpr pillars. If lawyers were involved, then they were deliberate to confuse the users.

The latest examples are the "accept or pay" pop-ups which are popular in Germany and France. They have been deemed illegal by the authorities and publications still use them.

I don't care about cookies – Get this Extension for 🦊 Firefox (en-US)

Download I don't care about cookies for Firefox. Get rid of cookie warnings from almost all websites!

@Techaltar Not an insane thing about the GDPR, it's an insane thing about malicious compliance. Make it too hard to set things up and people will give up, usually to your benefit. There are a lot of sensible consent systems, so this is a definite choice on their part.

I find the Cookie AutoDelete plugin to be incredibly useful in this environment. I no longer care whether they're maliciously compliant, as soon as the tab closes all their cookies disappear.

@Techaltar this is way out of order now, every single site we go now i have to untogle like 30.

@Techaltar this!!!
Only adjacently related, but I use Ghostery which, among other things, has an automatic cookie reject function. Works reasonably well for me.

https://www.ghostery.com/

Ghostery Ad Blocker | Best Free Ad Blocker & Privacy Tool

Take back control of your online privacy with Ghostery. The #1 privacy suite that gives you the power to block ads, stop trackers, and much more.

Ghostery