That picture looks off. Like the heads don’t match the bodies or something.

I thought so too, but the story checks out. Their engagement announcement was on page 7 of this local newspaper:

eaglevilletnhistory.com/print/Jan_2011.pdf

You have to read between the lines a bit: she was involved in FFA as a high schooler and graduated in 2007. He appears to have been involved in FFA extensively. It doesn’t mean for sure that they first met at an event where she was a student participant, but it seems likely. And of course, the age gap is the same either way.

Their engagement announcement was on page 7 of this local newspaper:

Looks like a nice father-daughter pic without any context.