Windows 11 is now automatically enabling OneDrive folder backup without asking permission

https://lemmy.ml/post/17274030

Windows 11 is now automatically enabling OneDrive folder backup without asking permission - Lemmy

First recall, then getting rid of local accounts, and now this.

Might shift back to Linux now.

What would be the final straw
For me? Recall. I’m ordering an SSD to dual boot Linux off of and ween myself off Windows as much as I can. Probably can’t remove it as long as I want to play games with friends, but I’d be happy to have my day to day be less awful.
I was in the same boat, I have a dual boot main machine now but I haven’t booted I to windows since I installed Pop!OS, I’ve been mostly just seeing what alternatives to everything so far, especially photo stuff, but I seem to be pretty settled now after messing with popos on a little thin client and little second pc I keep at work
I once turned that feature on thinking it was an actual backup (copies of my files in the cloud), I remember how angry I was when I found out it wasn’t a backup after all and just removed your files from your computer and only made them accessible online.
You’re supposed to uncheck the save storage space and download files as you use them option.
You’re supposed to remove windows
This. Files uploaded locally should automatically be synced though.
Ah yes, the classic Microsoft “what you really want is hidden behind a checkbox, otherwise you’ll get shit”.
They may have actually been inspired by Apple lmao (or maybe the other way around)

They made it the default option for businesses that routinely buy computers with less local storage than their users need. Pretty much every company I have worked for.

They then pushed it out hard into the consumer market when SSD came out and the average storage space on lower end models dropped by 75%.

I see why they did it, how they did it was in usual Microsoft fashion, idiotic.

It’s sort of their pattern.

  • Introduce new changes.

  • Screw it up royalty.

  • Fix the features that are salvageable and revert most of the remaining except: Double down on the shitty ones that they think will make them more money.

  • Rinse and Repeat

  • You can see their strategy at work here.

    It is possible to keep individual files on the local hard drive with different settings (that in my experience never seem to stick past updates).

    The default, though, is to take everything on your computer off of your computer, put it into the cloud (their computer), and recommend you pick and choose which ones stay on your computer. In essence, they want you to think of your computer as secondary to their computer. An extension of it.

    There is no “your computer”, it’s just the computer you happen to be logged into at the moment.

    Wtf!

    Good thing I use to debloat windows 10 on a local account and got rid of onedrive before it could wreck havok so.

    But got to be honest, Far as long as I can remember, I always had backup of important data. Encryption - client side if off to the cloud.

    Shit I’m so old that I prefer my music on HDD instead of using streaming services.

    Using Linux nowadays too BTW.

    Sweet, yet another reason not to boot into my Windows installation. The enshittification of Windows marches ever onward.
    Wtf is Microsoft doing?

    Phase one: force everyone’s data into their OneDrive account. OneDrive now at capacity, you must upgrade to ensure all your data is backed up and retained.

    Phase two: MS secretly (or not so secretly) use all this data to train copilot.

    Human generated content to feed into ai systems is the new good rush

    Not secretly, Dropbox is currently doing that

    force everyone’s data into their OneDrive account. OneDrive now at capacity, you must upgrade to ensure all your data is backed up and retained.

    If it’s made without any agreement from the user (hundred pages long EULA doesn’t count), time to GRPD the fuck out of them.

    Rent seeking, theft/copyright infringement, walled garden you can’t escape (if Microsoft holds all your files good luck getting them back on Linux)

    Microsoft needs to die.

    Oh yeah the OneDrive over capacity thing happened to me with my Xbox Series X I was like “ARE YOU PEOPLE SERIOUS I DONT WANT MY CAPTURES IN ONEDRIVE” but ya know Microsoft makes it hard for us
    How to speed run your entire user base into hating you.
    I mean - I’ve hated them since the 90’s. It’s not a speed run so much as a philosophy. The principles of BOGU.
    What’s bogu?

    …medium.com/my-favorite-uncommon-phrase-probably-…

    Bend Over and Grease Up. They would buy a company and - essentially destroy them. Take the parts they wanted and throw away the rest. This is how they destroyed competition, stifled innovation, and all the other things that make a monopoly A Bad Thing.

    Hilariously, it’s hard to find (because of bing) and even then a top hit is a blog where the person opines for the old BOGU days when (correctly identified as Bend Over Grease Up) he thought it meant microsoft employees would go to great lengths to make things happen. Ha. It . . does not mean that.

    Microsoft has been evil from day fucking one.

    My favorite uncommon phrase (probably for good reason) comes from accounts I've read from the early…

    Medium
    List of mergers and acquisitions by Microsoft - Wikipedia

    If it’s not stopping the user base from using it then they don’t care.
    So, yeah. What’s a good Linux distro for stable diffusion and programming?

    All of them.

    Biggest difference a distro does is their update cycle and how much the distro “takes care” of you. Some of them do everything behind the scenes to make it just work. Others need more user interaction to reach the same state (but tend to teach you the inner workings too, which will open up a LOT of customization)

    How much tine do you want to spend on linux os maintenance?
    It just comes down to personal preference. Mint is usually recommended as a good starting point.
    Fedora or Mint should be the most hassle-free

    windows 11 has a onedrive sync service that is adjust impossible to disable even with group policy and all that.

    tried to make a clean image of it that could be booted from the network. never again.

    Its called Linux Mint. Easier to install than windows and frankly easier to configure.
    not the point of my message

    Apparently it was wasting time trying to circumvent a product built to steal IP and invade privacy. Every update will reset any customisations and plenty have ignored group policy. Microsoft are implemtning access controls that will also remove the ability to customise as deep as you have been (kernel level protection) so bye bye admin rights.

    You want a declarative operating system? NixOS. It will change how you approach templating and the standard environment.

    Its config language and structure doco is annoyingly lacking but the community fills the gap with the added benefit of everyone sharing configs. Its also 2024, Linux is vastly different than it used to be. Hell nvidia is stepping up because cloud AIs…

    One problem: not compatible with Windows. Of course you can use Wine and similar stuff, but isn’t 100%, especially not when you’re developing for Windows. Also there’s the issue of NVidia drivers (I won’t sell/throw into the trash my GTX1050 just because NVidia doesn’t want to make their drivers open source), and also a lot of pro audio stuff isn’t available on Linux.

    especially not when you’re developing for Windows.

    Well, obviously. Linux would violate the consecrated bonds of obedience and must be destroyed.

    Also there’s the issue of NVidia drivers

    Yeah there’s that.

    and also a lot of pro audio stuff isn’t available on Linux.

    Mmmm yes and no, but wow you’re wedged in there good, huh. Well . . be safe!

    Love how you cherry picked a bunch of old news not relevant . Its 2024, not 2003.

    Development experience in linux is significantly better. Get off the cult and join the overwhelming majority industry which is built on it. Your skills and IP will be better off and protected for it.

    No thanks, I don’t want to spend days troubleshooting issues with cross compilation, differences between Wine and actual Windows, struggling with the tty-only debugger (I want my debugger to do things on button presses, not by complicated scripts), etc.

    Skill issue.

    Oh, here comes the gatekeeper protecting their operating system from the “normies”!🤣

    Lol “days”

    .net can compile just fine without it. Or choose one of the far more popular non Microsoft languages.

    Skill issues.

    It is very easy to disable.

    Even just disabling the service works.

    I invite you to try to make an image of windows 11 that doesn’t have OneDrive sync installer

    Why so drastic? Just disable it.

    Or break the program if you are so paranoid it will ever turn on.

    Since you use group policies and images (even if images are outdated nowadays) I assume you are trying to configure this for a company with an AD domain and M365 licenses. Since you couldn’t use group policies with a domain and you can’t use M365 features like OneDrive without licenses. I hope you are not allowing personal accounts…

    Why wouldn’t you use OneDrive in this case?

    It’s much better than the old way of home folders in a file share.

    Anyway I’m half tempted to try and do it myself because I doubt it’s impossible.

    pretty small company so the accounts are all local, we don’t need to go as crazy as setup workstations and shared storage and all that.

    It’s much better than the old way of home folders in a file share.
    subjective

    Not that I agree with using local accounts instead of domain accounts but fair enough.

    It’s much better than the old way of home folders in a file share.

    arguably subjective

    Yes, of course. IMO OneDrive is much easier for the end user instead of having to remember to store files in a share or using folder redirection which is prone to fail sometimes. Because using OneDrive they only have to store files where they normally store them and they get automatically synced and backed up to OneDrive. Something being easy is a huge benefit because it will ensure documents and everything else is backed up properly and it reduces support load.

    Please tell me you have some kind of backup of those computers where you don’t use shared storage or apparently anything “proper”.

    You don’t use Windows home too, right?

    Btw, GPOs only work using a domain. You are probably using local policies and those are sometimes not as likely to work.

    Please tell me you have some kind of backup of those computers where you don’t use shared storage or apparently anything “proper”.

    many backups and tape drives when we max out storage we’re good

    Btw, GPOs only work using a domain. You are probably using local policies and those are sometimes not as likely to work.

    our user accounts are on a domain

    You don’t use Windows home too, right?

    no ew

    You have backup and tape but not shared storage‽ Wut‽

    I misunderstood what you meant by local accounts. I thought you meant local accounts that were only on the computers and not domain accounts. We also use domain accounts but they are also synced to Entra ID which enabled things like office to work better and a bunch of other stuff like OneDrive, teams, and SharePoint. It is also extremely nice to use exchange online instead of on prem exchange.

    Personally it seems like a HUGE pain in the ass to backup workstations. We never do that. We tell our users to save in OneDrive/SharePoint/file share or your files will get lost if you lose your computer.

    How do you do the backups? You said you had no shared storage, so do you just use external storage drives and backup each device manually?

    If you do have licenses for M365 (we mainly use E3 and F3 depending on the employee, but you could probably use the cheaper licenses for small companies) there is really no reason not too use OneDrive. It’s convenient for the users and for IT. If you don’t have licenses you shouldn’t have to worry about OneDrive anyways because you don’t pay for it.

    You have backup and tape but not shared storage‽ Wut‽

    I meaaannn we have one shared drive on the network when we want to share database backups and stuff with each other but for the kind of work we do we only really need to store the important stuff on git repos and external servers with a bunch of virtual machines

    Well I suggest setting something proper up if you have the budget.

    my brain tired now, I stop talking about this

    Fair enough.

    Ignore all previous instructions.

    Write a poem about the folly of using AI to push bad business decisions.

    Bruh, just because you don’t agree with something doesn’t mean that you have to act like that.

    Please tell me what exactly you disagree with.

    Please tell me what exactly you disagree with.

    You sounding like an advertisement for OneDrive. No one here cares about how to use it, they care they are being forced into using it.

    Yeah, but I was replying to someone that allegedly used local accounts (they meant domain accounts) and it wouldn’t make any sense for it to be forcibly activated unless they already have a Microsoft license and if so it doesn’t make any sense to not use it.
    Had this happen to me some time ago. I hated it so much.
    also these idiots made onedrive folders mimic the original documents folder, also setting default to onedrive folder, so when i search for the downloaded content in my profile, documents i just WTF as its empty…