Reading Mastodon and listening to podcasts it has become accepted truth that only subscription pricing makes software development sustainable. That having users pay once is irresponsible.

But the underlying fallacy is that every user should make you profit.

To be sustainable your users collectively need to pay you enough and with millions of future users it is very possible to just have income from new users.

You still want to cater to existing users. Their goodwill will bring in new users.

A pure software rental model always triggers a look at alternatives for me, and I’ve switched away from some long-used products because of this (Text Expander comes to mind.) I’m perfectly happy with lifetime or major version buyouts, as there is a clear value exchange there. On the goodwill point, I also agree that the Working Copy model is clear value for my money, and have been happy to take lifetime buyouts of @palmin ’s other apps because of this (plus the apps are great!)