@Schiraki I guess this is kind of why I liked Dream Daddy, despite being neither a guy nor wishing to be a parent. The relationships (from what I rember) are mostly different flavours of wholesome and the two men who are trouble or have serious problems or both... The game isn't really sugarcoating this aspect.
(That said, many interactions are between your family and each dad x's family, so they don't talk a lot about your other meetings with other dads to begin with.)