@Phreba @atownstyle @chris @ry_storm Alex is phenomenal. Not sure I can decide on Cotter vs Alex yet.
A little will depend on whether Rick eventually lets Cotter lead and influence direction more.
I think Goose fans are all assuming that since Cotter seems clearly superior to Ben that it will open up the jams to new directions. But the reality is unless Rick does more listening, the jams will stay 90+ percent Rick, just with a busier rhythm section.
@justinbruce @Phreba @atownstyle @chris @ry_storm I thought Rick played phenomenal and seemed very happy and inspired which led to great things.
FWIW, I don’t think there is anything wrong with Goose jams. The best Phish is often not very democratic—especially in 1.0, 2.0, and pre-2017 3.0.
But a lot of people seem to think that adding Cotter is going to make things more democratic. I just didn’t hear it at the cap. Rick was still his dominant self—which is not a bad thing.
@chopaganda @justinbruce @Phreba @atownstyle @chris there was definitely less Rick forward shredfests at the cap but the real question is whether that was a novelty or has staying power
Summer tour will be telling