It's important to understand that "age verification" schemes being passed by states, ostensibly to "protect the children", won't do that and will bring about incredible abuses.

In order to age verify children, obviously EVERYBODY of any age must be verified, for every account, under every name or pseudonym, ultimately on every site no matter how public or private the topic, and before downloading any apps.

Children will find ways to work around this. They'll use the accounts of adults, which will be openly traded. But because these age verification systems must by definition be based on government IDs, the verification process creates a linkage between your account names and your actual identity, subjecting you to all manner of leaked personal information, government abuses (think MAGA in charge), and worse. Firms will claim their systems either don't keep this data or can't be abused. History strongly suggests otherwise, and when courts step in, those firms will have to do what the courts say, often in secret, when it comes to collecting data.

Age verification is in actuality a massive Chinese-style Internet identity tracking project -- nothing less -- and there are many politicians in the U.S. who look with envy at how China controls their Internet and keeps their Internet users under police state controls.

@lauren There is a government maintained baseline on what to censor in China. While this is not the case in America, platforms like Facebook and X are free to censor as they like, and they censor outright antisemitism as much as China censors outright anticommunism.

Free speech is never unlimited.

@makendo The situations are not comparable, even putting aside that X no longer censors antisemitism or much of anything else under Musk. In China when you violate content rules -- with content strictly monitored along a wide range of different content types -- you may be arrested and simply vanish -- depending on the specific offense. Key to this is the ability to track what every user does at every site. This is specifically what U.S. age verification schemes would ultimately enable, and doing so would be irresistible to either party in control at any given time, under one pretext or another.