📌 Via Tamar Hallerman: 1/...

Coming at 1 pm: closing arguments from Fulton election defendants who are arguing #FaniWillis should be disqualified from the case. We're also expecting both sides to try and submit additional evidence, incl text messages, cell records and an affidavit #Georgia #legal

Live stream here: https://www.youtube.com/@judgescottmcafee/streams

Among today's spectators: Scott Grubman, att'y who rep'd defendant Ken Chesebro. Former Dekalb CEO and gubernatorial candidate Vernon Jones is also back

Bevor Sie zu YouTube weitergehen

2/ Hallerman:

Here are some of the things I'm watching for:

- Any hints from McAfee on how he could rule
- Whether he admits any new evidence, allows new testimony
- How defense attorneys interpret Terrence Bradley's testimony

3/ Hallerman:

Judge McAfee confirms that defense attorneys have asked for 90 mins to divide between themselves for closing statements. He's giving prosecutors the same amount of time

Scott McAfee's Zoom Hearing

YouTube

5/ NBC:

John Merchant, Roman's defense attorney, is starting his closing arguments, focusing on what he alleges is a conflict of interest on Willis' part.

Via live blog: https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/donald-trump/live-blog/trump-cases-live-updates-fani-willis-rcna140536

Trump Florida case still without a trial date, Georgia judge hears summations in misconduct allegations against Fani Willis: Highlights

Donald Trump attended the classified documents hearing, which could determine a timeline for trial. Later in the day, a judge heard closing arguments on the effort to remove Fani Willis from Trump's Georgia election interference case.

NBC News
6/ Watching this. Merchant is saying that Willis had a "personal interest" in the way this goes, and if he gets overruled, he'll "come back" and do this all over again. (appellate court)

7/ NBC:

Roman alleged that Willis skirted the rules to appoint Wade and that she benefited financially from his appointment, which has earned his office over $600,000 to date.

8/ "There's enough facts in front of you, you know it when you see it," Merchant says of what constitutes a disqualifying conflict.

He's arguing that the standard for removing the DA from the case is an appearance of conflict, not an actual conflict.

9/ "We couldn't care less if they had a personal relationship outside of work," Merchant says of Willis and Wade. "They were dating for two years and then she awarded him a contract" where Fulton money ended up in his pockets. He says $9200 of Wade's trip spending unaccounted for
10/ 🤦🏻‍♀️ John Merchant invoked a quote from a Supreme Court decision on obscenity written by Justice Potter Stewart saying that when it comes to pornography, "I know it when I see it." He said that the allegations of misconduct against Willis fit this threshold of appearance of impropriety.

11/ Sadow is up now.

I detest him.

12/ Hallerman:

Trump's attorney Steve Sadow is up next. He's evoking Willis speech at Big Bethel AMEChurch, during which she said critics were playing the "race card." Sadow says it represented "a calculated determination by Ms. Willis to prejudice" a jury against the defendants

13/ FYI, this is about Squeaky:

As part of his closing arguments, John Merchant defended his wife Ashleigh, a lawyer for Trump co-defendant Michael Roman who led much of the witness questioning in this case.

"I will resist the temptation to defend my wife, who I believe to be an excellent lawyer," John Merchant told the judge, adding, "but i will say this, judge: you don’t just evaluate the credibility of the witness list. You evaluate the credibility of the lawyers."

more...

14/ cont'd:

Merchant said Adam Abbate, a lawyer for the state, "stood up here in open court ... and called her a liar."

"For the state to get up here and impugn her credibility" is inappropriate, Merchant added.

15/ Hallerman:

Sadow says there is a "legitimate concern based on the evidence of this case of (Willis and Wade's) truthfulness." He cites the testimony of former Willis friend Robin Yeartie and texts between ex-Wade law partner Terrence Bradley and attorney Ashleigh Merchant

Specifically, Sadow mentions Bradley's text “absolutely” when Merchant asked him if he believe Wade’s relationship with Willis began before she hired him

16/ Via Acyn:

Judge McAfee on Bradley text messages: In these text messages, is it ever definitively shown how he knew this… Usually if a state has a witness that goes sideways, they've got him locked in.., we don’t have that here

17/ NBC:

Trump's lawyer Steve Sadow told the judge that he didn't have to decide in this hearing that Willis and Wade lied. He said that what he had to do is "make a finding of the fact that you have genuine legitimate concerns about their credibility and their truthfulness."

Sadow then pushed the judge on the threshold for misconduct, saying that it only needed to be a "preponderance of evidence."

18/JHC.

Hallerman:

Craig Gillen, attorney for David Shafer, says Willis' strategy for her church speech was "deflection." She did two other "reprehensible" things for a lawyer or prosecutor, he said, play "the race card and the God card."

"She chose to inject race into the minds of the listeners and virtually everybody in this community," including people who could serve as jurors down the line, Gillen said. He calls it "premeditated."

19/ Hallerman:

Next up is Richard Rice, attorney for Bob Cheeley. He points to sheer volume of Willis-Wade texts, which tallies up to 10,000 text messages in 11 months, or roughly 30 a day.

“I don’t even think lovestruck teenagers communicate that much," he says

20/ Rice says Willis and Wade have track record of not being truthful. He points to Willis twice certifying on her ethics forms that she didn't accept gifts higher than $100. He alleges that Wade lied on his interrogatories in his divorce case about not being with other women

21/

Tamar Hallerman:

As he closes, Rice cites Judge McBurney's ruling on Burt Jones. If Willis was DQed for holding a fundraiser for a political opponent, then what Willis has done here "creates an actual conflict," he says

22/ Judge will allow no rebuttal from anti-Willis assholes.

Next up will be Willis side for 90 min. 5 min break.

I think judge said Team Asshole could reserve 5 mins for something but couldn't hear, sorry.

23/ We're back
24/ Now sitting at the prosecution table: DA Fani Willis
25/ Team Willis is calling out lies by Team Asshole.

26/ Prosecutor Adam Abbate says defendants have made many "material misrepresentations."

Says Robin Yeartie's testimony was “at best inconsistent… vague, very little description when asked in a very leading manner.”

27/ Abbate says the defense has to show an “actual conflict,” that Willis gained a financial benefit and got it based upon the outcome of the case. “They still got nowhere” during evidentiary hearing, he says

28/ NBC:

The prosecution gets underway with their closing arguments, with Abbate saying, “I am strongly bringing to the Court’s attention that the claims that were made were material misrepresentations. He's referencing MacDougald’s claims that the prosecutors knew Bradley was perjuring himself.

@GottaLaff

this guy is not doing a lot for me... could they have gotten someone better?... he's the Chief Deputy District Attorney, Major Crimes Division... but I'm just not feeling it.

@tdwllms1 He's dry. What matters are his arguments.

@GottaLaff

I think I get his line... that team criminal trumpers are arguing that it's only necessary that an "appearance of impropriety" even a small appearance is all that is needed to have the team Fani attorneys removed.... and they brought up cases that were claiming appearance only... this guy is arguing those cases indicated a concrete impropriety and not just an appearance... thus negating their argument... you probably see that also. just my thought...

@tdwllms1 Yes, that's why I said he may be dry, but if he's convincing, dry is fine.