Good

Care to elaborate why you think that’s good?

Because their claim is bullshit and they were trying to defraud a system used for cases of actual persecution.

Right, because only people you approve of can be persecuted. Whatever, dude…

Because it doesn’t take an academic to understand the difference between a domestic dispute being taken advantage of and someone who’s being ethnically cleansed by a regime.

If this person was a trans person from Afghanistan then that absolutely would have been a justified refugee claim.

As much as I’d like to concede the point, it sure sounds like more than a run of the mill domestic dispute. However, I will say other than that, I can see the basis of your argument.