Computers make mistakes and AI will make things worse — the law must recognize that

https://lemmy.world/post/11117028

Computers make mistakes and AI will make things worse — the law must recognize that - Lemmy.World

We spent decades on educating people that “computers don’t make mistakes” and now you want them to accept that they do?

We filled them with shit, that’s what. We don’t even know how that shit works, anymore.

Let’s be honest here.

I agree with this distinction, but ultimately if you are at the receiving end of a decision made my either a classic algorithm or an machine learning algorithm, and a mistake is made… You probably won’t care whether it was the computer making the mistake or the programmer making the mistake.

if you are at the receiving end of a mistake made my either a classic algorithm or an machine learning algorithm, then you probably won’t care whether it was the computer or the programmer making the mistake

I’m absolutely expecting corporations to get away with the argument that “they cannot be blamed for the outcome of a system that they neither control nor understand, and that is shown to work in X% of cases”. Or at least to spend billions trying to.

And in case you think traceability doesn’t matter anyway, think again.

IMHO it’s crucial we defend the “computers don’t make mistakes” fact for two reasons:

  • Computers are defined as working through the flawless execution of rational logic. And somehow, I don’t see a “broader” definition working in the favor of the public (i.e. less waste, more fault tolerant systems), but strictly in favor of mega corporations.
  • If we let the public opinion mix up “computers” with the LLMs that are running on them, we will get even more restrictive ultra-broad legislation against the general public. Think “3D printers ownership heavily restricted because some people printed guns with them” but on an unprecedented scale. All we will have left are smartphones, because we are not their owners.
  • Fujitsu apologizes for software bugs that fueled wrongful convictions in UK

    Fujitsu exec: "Bugs and errors" aided wrongful prosecutions of UK postal workers.

    Ars Technica