I have a question for fediverse heads. Threads is federating with a bunch of the fediverse, but a lot more are "oh noes, EEE!!!!!!!?!" and actively blocking it. Which seems counterproductive, and quite a bit scaremongery.

Does anyone have an actual instance where Embrace Extend Extinguish actually worked? I mean, sun sued MS for it over Java and as far as I can tell Java is still doing fine. They wanted to EEE Linux too, back on the day. Again, seems to be doing fine....

The biggest thing people point to is some rando's account of the death of XMPP. Which didn't actually happen? Sure, google defederated gtalk from XMPP, but quite honestly, I dunno if the author has a severe case of rose tinted glasses but XMPP was SHIT. No image support, no media support, no voice support, no room support. It was fucking awful and the protocol frozen for years. I remember searching for old gtalk friends on XMPP and finding out this had happened myself. I switched to matrix.
It's like everyone is convinced that somehow zuck is going to kill masto and the entire fediverse. Which is just whack. First, this is an EU "we're good guys" play by meta. Killing it is just dumb. Second, how will it exactly play out? I'm never going to sign up for threads or a meta account again, so I won't be using their stuff. It's neat but not a necessary condition of my social media that people there can read it if they wish. So, again, how is this anything but, heh ok cool I guess?
A quick tldr: has EEE ever actually worked? Can you point to a thing that was successfully squashed in the open source arena? I can think of a few proprietary products that have been squashed by other proprietary products, but nothing that's an open spec or standard. Most shit just does because it doesn't keep up with modern trends.
@cpw Can't say that I'm aware of any instance of it working (though if it ever had, it's probably because whatever it replaced was too small to make it through the process, so I doubt people would remember it.) I will say, though, that part of why EEE has never visibly succeeded is because people involved with the targeted projects refuse to give in. Users refuse to change, and devs refuse to concede to the "extensions". Open Source has a very important connection with choice. Choice of software, choice of interaction, choice of change. I don't think I personally would care one way or another if I ever saw a thread message, but I also know I can go to another instance if I really wanted to. Heck, I can move my entire account if needed. But the main thing is that EEE is fought by people who care, so I'm ok with instance owners making a choice on it.

I'm not, however, ok with people bullying others for making a choice. That I'll 100% agree on.