Judge: Amazon “cannot claim shock” that bathroom spycams were used as advertised

https://lemmy.world/post/9278094

Judge: Amazon “cannot claim shock” that bathroom spycams were used as advertised - Lemmy.World

>After a spy camera designed to look like a towel hook was purchased on Amazon and illegally used for months to capture photos of a minor in her private bathroom, Amazon was sued. > >The plaintiff—a former Brazilian foreign exchange student then living in West Virginia—argued that Amazon had inspected the camera three times and its safety team had failed to prevent allegedly severe, foreseeable harms still affecting her today. > >Amazon hoped the court would dismiss the suit, arguing that the platform wasn’t responsible for the alleged criminal conduct harming the minor. But after nearly eight months deliberating, a judge recently largely denied the tech giant’s motion to dismiss. > >Amazon’s biggest problem persuading the judge was seemingly the product descriptions that the platform approved. An amended complaint included a photo from Amazon’s product listing that showed bathroom towels hanging on hooks that disguised the hidden camera. Text on that product image promoted the spycams, boasting that they “won’t attract attention” because each hook appears to be “a very ordinary hook.”

Tech legal expert Eric Goldman wrote that a victory for the plaintiff could be considered “a dangerous ruling for the spy cam industry and for Amazon,” because “the court’s analysis could indicate that all surreptitious hook cameras are categorically illegal to sell.” That could prevent completely legal uses of cameras designed to look like clothes hooks, Goldman wrote, such as hypothetical in-home surveillance uses.

In what reality is there any need for a door-hook camera except to spy on someone who has not given consent???

Jayzuz. That was some poor mind gymnastics right there.

Watching the babysitter if you think she’s abusing your kids.

Monitoring your office if you’re a politician afraid of poisoning.

Making an OnlyFans of Grandma pooping.

Lots of legitimate uses if you’re creative enough.

Watching the babysitter if you think she’s abusing your kids. *In the bathroom? Cause that’s where towel hooks are.?

Monitoring your office if you’re a politician afraid of poisoning. See above

My jokes aside, I absolutely have towel hooks in non bathrooms. It’s turns out there also capable of holding jackets and other things, despite the name.

And also, the bathroom seems like a prime location for a child abuser to corner a victim.

Huh. I'm actually swinging very slightly back toward Amazon's side on this. Only very slightly, though. This is a tricky case.

If you think the baby sitter is abusing your kid, your a moron, why even hire him/her.

And now you are also recording the babysitter going to the bathroom.