@rosanita combs' version is inferior IMO. the emotion she evokes in hers is so powerful, i can barely stand to listen to it. his feels very slightly more uptempo, & it has an almost upbeat feel to it, which is fine i guess.. but hers is far better.
that said, i suppose it's pretty cool that she is getting this recognition & making some country music history. always weird to me to still see first black person to do such & such in 2023. we'll always have work to do.