Well, this is something!

https://lemm.ee/post/12727327

Well, this is something! - lemm.ee

::: spoiler Meanwhile in Germany: [https://www.cleanenergywire.org/sites/default/files/styles/large/public/images/factsheet/fig3-share-energy-sources-gross-german-power-production-2017.png?itok=pT6aOwO-] :::

You are aware that this is over 5 years old data (2017!) for the German electricity mix, right?

Please don’t get me wrong, the scale up of renewable energy sources is certainly not going fast enough in Germany (thanks to our conservative government that ruled the country for 16 years until 2021!), but please argue this position using the real data for 2023 (57.7% renewables in the German electricity mix)!

And please don’t forget that Germany exports 26.3% of its electricity, while France imports 16.4% of it.

So, Germany could cut 26.3% of its fossil fuel generation and go up to 84% renewables if countries like France wouldn’t depend on it that much.

This year is an anomaly because nuclear production was low because some power plants had to shut down for maintenance. Germany typically imports power from France.

Germany typically imports power from France.

2017 called, it wants to ask when anomalies become the normal.

I have found this nice article (in French) :
fr.linkedin.com/…/exportations-délectricité-franç…

It’s … more complex than one picture.

The average idea is that :

  • if you consider physical exchange directly between France and Germany, on the average, France massively exports to Germany.
  • but most of the electricity shared between Germany and France goes through Swiss. Swiss has dams to store energy. Germany has many surplus of production with renewables. Swiss is used for transit. As a result, Germany is a net exportator of electricity to France.
Exportations d’électricité françaises en Allemagne : en finir avec un mythe

La France exporte beaucoup d’électricité : 86,3TWh en 2018 [1]. Si cela ne vous parle pas, cela équivaut à la consommation électrique de l’Île de France + la Bretagne [2].