We thought Google hit rock bottom with #privacy.

Its new beta feature on Google Files for #Android called “Smart Search" is the trap door.

This creepy new feature on by default & scans every file on your phone. Why is this bad? Because it could potentially ruin your life. (1/3)

As Smart Search scours your phone, if it finds something it thinks (keyword: *think*) is CSAM, it can potentially shut down your Google account forever and flag you as a criminal. If you're deeply ingrained in Google’s ecosystem, losing your account would be devastating. (2/3)
@protonmail
Where is the documentation where it says it includes the CSAM feature ? Do you have any source for this ?
How Image Hashing Technology Helps NCMEC - Google Safety Center

National Center for Missing & Exploited Children’s Michelle DeLaune on how Google’s image hashing technology helps improve the review process of CSAM.

@protonmail
I know this platform, and the fact that Google has reported to the police different cases, but I do no see the precise point where it's linked to this feature of Google Files app.

From what I know, Google scans its services (mail, drive, etc.) but I had no clue that it includes CSAM via this feature of the app.

@sebsauvage
Yep, it would seem a *big* reach if they'd start to employ client-side scanning (Apple considered it, and were promptly shot down by privacy organizations). If they did, why would they do it in an optional file manager app, instead of a system framework?

The other option would be that Files uploaded local documents to the cloud for indexing. That doesn't seem super likely, either.

I, too, would like to see some evidence.
@protonmail

@osma @sebsauvage Indeed, what you're inferring @protonmail seems quite an accusation.

1) The existence of that API does not mean that it has been integrated with this app. The feature *could* legitimately index file content so that users would be able to search on contents.
2) If client-side scanning were to be added based on legal requirements, this probably wouldn't be a toggle-able feature. It would probably also be baked into the OS.

FUD without evidence reflects poorly on your brand IMO.

@elkarrde Ne mogu komentirati proizvod jer ga ne poznajem niti sam ovlasten komentirati u javnosti, no ovaj thread komentara postavlja dobra pitanja koja su i meni odmah prosla kroz glavu kad sam vidio clickbaity naslov prvog posta 🙂
@merlinrebrovic Ideja mog boosta je bila više generalno upozorenje nego išta konkretno, taj app nit ne postoji na mom mobu (ni Files ni Proton), ali da, pitanja su potpuno na mjestu!
Ide deboost jer nije baš sve tak čisto kak je implicirano.