So, if I were going to make a tech manifesto, it might be something like:

- protocols not platforms
- coops and unions
- technology should not actively hurt us
- people not users
- seven generations, seven continents
- free markets require antitrust enforcement

@evan I'd prefer a model which is not as adversarial as unions are. The "co-determination” system in Germany is a good system where workers elect representatives to a company's supervisory board. This way the direction of the company and policies are directly influenced by workers. The current system the US has where workers must go on strike without pay for weeks or months to get fair contracts is harmful to workers as we saw with the writers strike.

By law, companies with more than 2,000 employees must have an equal number of worker elected representatives on the board. This reduces the friction between workers and management while ensuring workers have a voice and significant influence.

@brennansv @evan Also the legal form dubbed 'worker coop' in the UK doesn't exist in many other legislations.

Here in the EU, if not trying to harmonise cooperative legislation, there are attempts at new legal forms where shared ownership is a mandatory quality.

So far the cooperatives movement has found different implementations throughout the globe, and we need to learn a lot more from each other how to use existing and advocate for new legal forms for fruitful ecosystems.

@yala @brennansv @evan

This BBC Horizon's 1980 documentary on the Mondragon Experiment might be interesting. Talks about how they developed somewhat organically based on the needs of the community, from manufacturing to education to banking.

https://archive.org/details/TheMondragonExperiment

The Mondragon Experiment : David Whitson, Michael Gore, Geoff Moore 1961-, Alexander John, Off Center Video. : Free Download, Borrow, and Streaming : Internet Archive

This film explores the cooperatives of Mondragon, Spain as a model of industrial and community development that can guide the future.

Internet Archive
Mondragon: Spain's giant co-operative where times are hard but few go bust

The northern Spanish town is dominated by its eponymous €15bn corporation that controls over 100 smaller co-ops

The Guardian
@brennansv Mitbestimmungsgesetz has been established after unions threatened with strikes and in most cases unions take part in this process.
@evan
@brennansv @evan unions are only as adversarial as management makes them be

@brennansv @evan Unions are not fundamentally adversarial. Workers have a huge vested interest in the success of the work that they do.

The idea of trade unions being a drag on productivity and corporate performance is propaganda promulgated by capitalists to make it easier for them to exploit labour without hindrance.

In any organisation with fair and equitable employment and compensation policies, the trade union is an ally, not an opponent.

@brennansv @evan no. any labour representative in a for-profit company would immediately get sidelined by "infinite growth"-cultist investors bringing everything back to square one.

the true solution to this is worker-owned co-ops, where the investor class is cut out of the arrangement entirely.

in for-profit, hierarchical models, unions *are* the compromise. anything less is pandering.

@evan this definitely sounds like a psychopath, from a silicon valley point of view 😜
@evan is definitely on Andreessen's "enemies" list, @rigo

@evan

> free markets require antitrust enforcement

THANK YOU

@evan I just saw a comment about a completely different topic, but it matches perfectly with your proposal:

"This is too much like common sense, rationality, and compassion. Totally won't fly." 🙂

Also, my thoughts on the manifesto: https://mas.to/@merlinrebrovic/111250411970629588

Merlin Rebrović (@[email protected])

Attached: 1 image This Techno-Optimist manifesto doing the rounds is one of the most delusional pieces of writing and thought I have read in a long time.

mas.to
@evan what does "seven generations" refer to? Or should I wait for the manifesto!
Evan Prodromou (@[email protected])

@[email protected] @[email protected] I made it up. "Seven generations" is a term that means thinking three generations backwards and three forwards. Seven continents is one way of dividing up the world, meaning, don't just think of the US and maybe Europe.

CoSocial

@Brendanjones @evan Thanks! What an idea, click around and explore more before asking a question! 😅

Fully agree with the sentiment. It's a challenge to think about "generations" given how emphemoral software is, but maybe that's the point.

@derek @Brendanjones The Web is 30 years old, email is 40 years old. That's about 1 human generation back. Von Neumann architecture, some of our programming languages like FORTRAN, COBOL, and Lisp date back another 30 years or so.

@Brendanjones @derek @evan

Seven Generations is a term in some cultures that indicates long-term thinking.

I think Evan is drawing from an Indigenous / First Nations understanding. It means that you need to think about the impacts of your decisions for the next 7 generations.

But 7 generations is also found in the Judeo-Christian tradition. In the Bible, seven generations is a stand-in for eternity or a really long time. And in India, you get married for 7 lifetimes (basically forever).

@seanbala @Brendanjones @derek yeah, I think the link to Native American traditions is tenuous and may be some kind of exoticism or cultural fabrication.

@evan @Brendanjones @derek

Thanks for the check. That sounds about right. I wonder if there was a hint of truth but it has been so altered that it has lost all rooted meaning like how mindfulness in the West is usually divorced from its Buddhist context.

Considering 7 generations is a nice concept and doesn't need the roots in some mystical exotic.

I figured it was a clever turn of phrase in your post. 7 generations and continents sounds nice to the ear.

@evan @ntnsndr I like, though “technology should not actively hurt us” feels a bit like a bare minimum! Surely that requirement can be raised higher, and maybe framed positively.

Also something about non-human impact would be nice, something about minimising material & energy footprint.

@Brendanjones @ntnsndr you should definitely include those in your manifesto.
@evan @ntnsndr Haha touché. But no need, I’m enjoying critiquing yours from my armchair 😉 (I am enjoying the thought experiment, it’s good to think about these things, so thanks for the prompt)
@evan @ritawho But the reality is the world doesn’t need *any* tech manifestos period. They’re all just techies masturbating in public and expecting praise. Maybe just focus on not enshittifying the world instead.

@evan I haven't heard "seven generations, seven continents" before, and my search skills aren't bringing up anything useful.

What does it mean?

(I can try to guess from context, but would rather hear it from you, if you're willing to share.)

Evan Prodromou (@[email protected])

@[email protected] @[email protected] I made it up. "Seven generations" is a term that means thinking three generations backwards and three forwards. Seven continents is one way of dividing up the world, meaning, don't just think of the US and maybe Europe.

CoSocial
@evan I would go further. Our data should be content-addressable, and communication should be protocol-agnostic. We should get rid of data vendor lock-in.
@functionalscript I look forward to reading your manifesto.
@evan It's good to know that you care what others think.
@evan @mmasnick already wrote that first one several years back.
Protocols, Not Platforms: A Technological Approach to Free Speech

Knight First Amendment Institute
@evan @mmasnick oh, interesting! we think, to promote adoption, it might be worthwhile to focus on fallback behaviour, and we made #FediLinks for this ( https://fedilinks.org ). it's mainly intended to improve interoperability between fedi instances and apps, but we've been struggling to gather adoption from instances and we think better client/app support for fallbacks would help push for instance support.
Fedi Links

@evan there's a lot of possible acronyms...like

PANACEA: Protocols And Networks Advancing Coops, Unions, And Ensuring Antitrust

@evan I‘m unsure what seven generations, seven continents refers to. Internationalization/localization of software? Making it accessible to old and young people?
Evan Prodromou (@[email protected])

@[email protected] @[email protected] I made it up. "Seven generations" is a term that means thinking three generations backwards and three forwards. Seven continents is one way of dividing up the world, meaning, don't just think of the US and maybe Europe.

CoSocial

@evan why seven generations?

edit: scrolled down and saw the 3 back and 3 forward stuff. good thought.

important to think about those older and sometimes wiser, as well as those younger or yet to arrive.

@evan speaking of which, I’m going to incorporate a co-op today on my birthday! triangle.coop https://github.com/Triangle-Co-op/triangle-co-op-documents, made with the people I made galaxies.dev with.
GitHub - Triangle-Co-op/triangle-co-op-documents: Triangle foundational, operations & policy documents

Triangle foundational, operations & policy documents - GitHub - Triangle-Co-op/triangle-co-op-documents: Triangle foundational, operations & policy documents

GitHub
@brettpeary @evan So I bookmarked this (checks timestamp) ... almost 2 wks ago? Just coming back and wow! This Dojo4 policy repo is such a great resource! And the main docs you point to in your repo seem to lead mainly to the Notion template and the Lean Co-Op course? I'm saving this for a later date but want to make sure I don't miss anything, and thanks for sharing! 🙏 😊
@jgaehring yeah, that’s basically it! It’s all there in the readme. Are you making a co-op? What kind of co-op?
@brettpeary A workers coop to build network infrastructure and software tools for farmers and food workers, so they can run their own platform coops specific to their foodshed or bioregion. I've done poorly maintaining its early momentum, but don't want to rush it. The details are here:
https://runrig.org
Runrig

Runrig is a communal farming platform, a libre software project and a method of socio-ecological design. It aims for collective sovereignty over not just our food, but also the labor that raises it, the land and living things that support it, and the data connecting connecting it all.

@brettpeary Though I oughta add, @wright4thejob and I are still looking for more collaborators, if anyone is interested. Designers and engineers mostly, but experienced PM's, farm TSP's or ppl with a better head 4 biz than myself, so long as they're on board with "class struggle cooperativism," as Kali Akuno puts it.