Let them eat burgers! Austrian chancellor says low-income families should eat at McDonald’s

https://lemmy.ml/post/5819477

Let them eat burgers! Austrian chancellor says low-income families should eat at McDonald’s - Lemmy

I remember another time a rich leader offered dietary advice to the impoverished citizens. Let’s just say some people really lost their heads.
Feels like more and more conservatives are feeling comfortable saying the quiet part out loud.
Except for the fact that she never said any of that, it was Rousseau
It’s almost like that’s what the first line of the title is implying as well.
Idiot. That’s neither healthy nor sustainable. What’s his vision for his country?
Bleeding it dry? There was a thread in Mastodon recently proving there’s a massive supermarket cartel driving prices in Austria higher than in surrounding countries and the government took the side of the supermarkets.
Do you have a link to that? Would love to know more.

It's also nowhere near that cheap.

McD is hella expensive, especially if you have to live of of it.

A 8-10€ basic menu is good to fill in a single meal, but while having a ton of calories, doesn't satiate enough to count even as a full meal (which is on purpose so you order more). At my local prices, you're looking at 13-15€ minimum, to have a satiating meal out of McDonnalds.

The vision of his party is to keep everything the same, they’re conservatives
Except when it comes to businesses, or religion, usually.
ÖVP has been in government for decades. There is nothing they want to change in regards to these topics, because the status quo conforms to their ideas.
Too bad the world keeps changing, huh?

It’s not healthy, but it’s cheap: a hamburger at McDonald’s — €1.40, if I buy fries with it, €3.50.

3.50€ for a meal isn’t cheap and nothing a poor person can afford in a regular basis. I can cook a great meal for under 2€ that doesn’t consist of trash. What a detached asshole.

Yeah I don’t know about Austria but here McDonald’s ain’t that cheap.
Same here in Lithuania. McDonalds is way too expensive for people on a tight budget and what you get for the price is disappointing too. It’s cheaper and more delicious to make some burgers at home (which aren’t so dry that you must wash down every bite with a sip of Coke) or just to get a street kebab (which is slightly more expensive but actually fills you for the entire day and is nutritious).
Same in all Europe. Not cheap for the quality. Cooking at home the same burger is cheaper with better ingredients

Exactly. Not only is it not cheap on a regular basis, but it isn't even that much food from my experience at the cheaper end of McDonalds.

You'd be far better off cooking your own food if you have the time, but the problem is a lot of these people are so busy working their arses off to atay afloat that they don't have that time.

Those 1€ (1.40 in Austria apparently) burgers are barely enough to satiate a child, if combined with fries. They are nowhere near enough to feed an adult.

It’s been very long that these are 1€ here in Germany. Mcd is expensive and in a normal restaurant you can get very good meals for 15€.

Shows how detached these politicians really are.

The 1,40 burgers are barely enough to satiate a child, even with fries.

A menu that can fill an adult, that's 13-14€ easily. And that's still just one meal.

The quality 3 meals a day I consume and make at home average 5€ per portion. resulting in 450€ food budget per person per month, I generally go for white label products if the quality is good enough.

That's 900€ a month for 2 people for food alone (this was 300ish before COVID).
850-1000€ for entry level 1 bedroom rent here, brings us to 1750-1900€ a month for a roof and food, another 75-100 for electricity (and then you have to be very usage conscious) brings us to 1825-2000€ a month, add required insurance (fire/health/accidents) for another 50-100€ brings us to 1875-2100€ a month.

Now, a phone and internet sub are pretty much a requirement these days, so say the cost of a cheap phone, internet and gsm abbo combine to be another 50€ a month per person.

So we're at 1975-2200€ a month to cover the very basic living expenses for a 2 person household.

You'd need to have one person with a decent wage or two people working minimum wage to barely get by.

Any surprise or extra cost and you're in the red.

Eating McDonnalds to cover breakfast, lunch and dinner every day, you'd need over 2000€ for food alone.

The quality 3 meals a day I consume and make at home average 5€ per portion

That’s really very high, are you guessing or did you actually work it out for an average day?

Tbh eating quality food is simply expensive. It’s a thing where i wanna say you could easily save 10€ a day but it’d definitely be less healthy and eating unhealthily is ideally something people shouldn’t be forced to do because they’re poor.

Personally I eat out for lunch whenever I’m in the office (3-4 times a week) for 10€ and I spend less than 15€ on food a day. My regular meals at home are like… noodles with store bought pesto where ~4€ feed me an entire day, or frozen pizza which varies from 1-3.5€ per pizza. Though with some effort i could easily make my own pizzas for a similar (or even less if i make my own dough) price and have them be not unhealthy.

I also find 100€ for electricity to be pretty high (certainly not “very usage conscious”) given that I consume around 80kwh a month, and 2 people shouldn’t just double that since around a quarter is probably my fridge.

Tbh eating quality food is simply expensive.

I don’t really agree with that, if you mean in terms of money. Eating healthily can be very cheap, but can consume a lot of time and effort.

Take wholemeal rice with red kidney beans, for example - that’s a very healthy, filling meal and it’s also incredibly cheap.

Honestly, in my experience, the unhealthiest food also tends to be the worst value.

I’ll ask again because it’s important and you kinda brushed past it: have you actually properly checked - e.g. calculated price per 400 kcal, or are you just guessing based on your grocery budget?

I’m not op - i eat cheap (outside of my going out for lunch at work meals for 10€) but unhealthy. I did a quick estimate based on my cc charges in the last month and I don’t think I’m above 250€ a month, while eating out for lunch around 13-15 times a month… I definitely agree that 5€ per meal is a lot.

Tbh I’m not nutritionally educated enough to know how relevant this actually is, but I was under the impression that some variety of ideally fresh produce would be required for optimally healthy food, and that is what seems to be expensive to me. Otherwise yea, aldi spaghetti for 80 cents and whipping up a sauce without much fat for maybe 5 euros max (high estimate) wouldn’t be particularly unhealthy either and last a day, and much like your rice with beans example there are probably many meals like this.

Fresh produce is extremely cheap, if we’re talking about the same thing - how much is it for you to buy 2kg of potatoes, carrots and onions from the supermarket, and how much food can you make from that amount of veggies?
Yeah, even though fast food is often looked down upon, it’s actually a luxury food. I enjoy fast food about 3 times per week and it costs almost as much as all other groceries summed up. If i had to cut costs, this would be the first thing i’d cut. I would eat rice, legumes and tomato sauce instead (maybe with toppings like canned fish or tofu) would easily save >50€ per week. You can buy ceap high quality rice in huge sacks (often with zippers on top) to save even more.
McDonald’s is not cheap food, it’s fast food. I don’t expect this cunt to know the difference.
That’s not even enough to satiate you. For that you need to buy a menu which is about 10€ here in Germany. That’s not cheap at all.
As of July 2023, the price of a Big Mac (just the sandwitch) in the US is $5.58 (€5.27). statista.com/…/big-mac-in@dex-global-prices-for-a…
Big Mac index 2023 | Statista

Switzerland leads the Big Mac index as of July 2023. The index is a way of measuring whether currencies are over- or undervalued against each other.

Statista

If I could afford almost 4 quid per meal I’d be laughing! Think of all the nice food I could eat!

We grow all of our vegetables for most of the year. Potatoes, carrots, leeks, onions, tomatoes, cucumbers, lettuce, beetroot, lots of berries for jams, etc etc. I don’t know how we’d manage without that.

We live in the outskirts of a major city in England, not a stereotypically poor blackwater somewhere. This is how bad things are these days.

What can a banana cost?
3,50€ is really cheap in my country. But our grocery and restaurants prices are among the worse ones

According to Google that’s about $5 Canadian. The avegage burger combo at McDonald’s in my area is about $12. $15 if you upsize.

Not that eating healthier is much cheaper.

Nothing new for Austria. Lived there for 30+ years, it’s downhill and corruption all the way.
To be fair corruption and keeping people in cellars is about ¾ of our GDP.

Nobody in our country voted for that tone deaf asshole either. He was just “stepped in” as an interim after our prior catastrophe of a chancellor stepped down (Sebastian Kurz - He also made it to international media for his corruption).

Before representing our country as chancellor, this piece of shit was minister of the interior. - while being in this position he was just as useless as now. Words cannot describe how much I loathe this guy.

I personally couldnt care less if he was leading the party at the last elections or not. Nehammer is prime ÖVP, his politics is a perfect example of what you get when you vote for this party.
Who tf can afford to eat at McDonalds, have you seen their prices lately?
I think most people can afford to eat at McDonald’s.
I can afford it but with the current prices it makes no sense - last time I walked out with a $12 total. There’s a whole lot of better places to eat for that much
Why would I spend $50 on a hamburger, I can do more than one to myself with $10

His opinion used to be much more widespread 10 or 15 years ago. Now poor people can’t even eat fast food without being judged for wasting money.

He’s not just a capitalist pig, he’s an out of touch capitalist pig.

TBF, their prices are localized. Say, in Russia it was always not something you can do every day. They depend on many things, supply chain, general income levels, some central strategy. It’s a franchise, as everybody knows I’m sure. You can open a McDonalds in a place lacking one if they agree.

And the reason it’s comparatively expensive now somewhere as compared to 15 years ago is that they apparently think that being more expensive and smaller in volume is better for their operation than being less expensive and bigger in volume. Or something like that.

Did they go looking doe the most smug, I’m-an-asshole expression possible for that guy, or does he just look like that?
Not sure how things are in Austria but where I live fast food is really for someone strapped for cash

The sentiment remains disgusting no matter how factually accurate it is.

“I only have a few dollars to feed my children”

"Oh fuck have you tried giving it to billionaires?“

“So what does it mean that a child doesn’t get a hot meal in Austria? Do you know what the cheapest hot meal in Austria is? It’s not healthy, but it’s cheap: a hamburger at McDonald’s — €1.40, if I buy fries with it, €3.50. Now someone is seriously claiming that we live in a country where parents can’t afford this meal for their child,” he said.

“If I have too little money, I go to work more,” he added in the video, which was filmed during a wine-and-cheese event near Salzburg — with no burgers in sight — his conservative People’s Party confirmed to Plus24.

i hope he chokes to death on a piece of rotten cheese in his wine cave

Even disregarding this being a horrible choice for your child’s nutrition that’s a pretty horrible deal, you could get much more food by being cheap brands in the supermarket.

This guy is amazingly out of touch, normally EU politicians have the sense to refrain from such statements even if probably most of them believe the same.

lol, in my experience French conservative politicians are equally out of touch. They’re bourgeois fucks, they have no idea what a bus ticket costs. See this compilation from a few years ago

francetvinfo.fr/…/pain-au-chocolat-a-10-centimes-…

Pain au chocolat à 10 centimes, ticket de métro à 4 euros... Quand les politiques vivent dans un autre monde

Invité d'Europe 1, lundi, Jean-François Copé a évalué le prix d'un pain au chocolat à "10 ou 15 centimes". Mais ce n'est pas le premier politique à buter sur des questions de la vie quotidienne.

Franceinfo

‘It’s one banana, Michael. What could it cost, $10?’

Or even better:

C.J.: It’s not that I wanna don a shroud, I just think the Polly-Anna act’s not wearing well. Sir, I’m worried that at some point avoidance starts to look like maybe we just haven’t noticed. We run the risk of appearing out of touch, like one of those President’s who doesn’t know the price of milk. Sir, do you know the price of milk?
BARTLET: Not precisely.
C.J.: Neither do I. Do any of us?

wel to be fair I don’t know the price of milk and I buy milk at the store. That’s not information I memorise
You probably know the ballpark. They have no idea what the correct order of magnitude is
it’s been harder since the ukraine war as things keep getting more and more expensive rapidly

Milk has up to 30% pus in it where I’m from (legal limit). Who buys that crap anyway?

Bananas are less than a dollar per pound.