Upward of 20,000 Ukrainian amputees face trauma on a scale unseen since WWI

LVIV, Ukraine (AP) -- The small band of soldiers gather outside to share cigarettes and war stories, sometimes casually and sometimes with a degree of

https://mainichi.jp/english/articles/20230904/p2g/00m/0in/038000c

Upward of 20,000 Ukrainian amputees face trauma on a scale unseen since WWI - The Mainichi

LVIV, Ukraine (AP) -- The small band of soldiers gather outside to share cigarettes and war stories, sometimes casually and sometimes with a degree of

The Mainichi
I do not understand how they could publish something like this…
Why?
The Murder of People with Disabilities

At the beginning of WWII, people with mental or physical disabilities were targeted for murder in what the Nazis called the T-4, or "euthanasia," program.

why not?
…ushmm.org/…/the-murder-of-people-with-disabiliti… cause it’s a blatantly untrue statement that is also just comparing suffering of people for no actual reason and doesn’t justify it’s own take on why what it’s said is actually true.
The Murder of People with Disabilities

At the beginning of WWII, people with mental or physical disabilities were targeted for murder in what the Nazis called the T-4, or "euthanasia," program.

What statement do you mean is untrue?
Read the title of the article and the title of this post…

Title of this post: Upward of 20,000 Ukrainian amputees face trauma on a scale unseen since WWI

The title of your article: The Murder of People with Disabilities - The Nazis saw people with disabilities as an obstacle in their attempts to create an idealized “German race.” In 1939, the Nazi regime began a systematic program to murder them.

Is your problem with the fact that they say “since WWI”? Your “wink wink, nudge nudge, get what I mean” explanation makes no sense lol. Just say what you mean, unless you’re implying something terrible and don’t want to say it out loud?

Ok ok hear me out. I spent way too much time trying to figure out wtf that guy was talking about. I’m like 80% sure he/she was taking issue with the word “trauma” in the title. And then trying to say that disabled people had worse trauma in nazi Germany
Sheesh, I need to brush up on my English
Your english skills have nothing to do with this, the dude was being extremely vague on purpose.
What exactly is the statement you are talking about? The title? I read it as “there haven’t been this many amputees in a country since ww1 and this is what they are going through”
Even this is hard to believe given many other wars happened in between. E.g., the genocide in Rwanda (journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/jour…)
A Decade Later, How Much of Rwanda's Musculoskeletal Impairment Is Caused by the War in 1994 and by Related Violence?

Background In 1994 there was a horrific genocide in Rwanda following years of tension, resulting in the murder of at least 800,000 people. Although many people were injured in addition to those killed, no attempt has been made to assess the lasting burden of physical injuries related to these events. The aim of this study was to estimate the current burden of musculoskeletal impairment (MSI) attributable to the 1994 war and related violence. Methodology/Principal Findings A national cross-sectional survey of MSI was conducted in Rwanda. 105 clusters of 80 people were selected through probability proportionate to size sampling. Households within clusters were selected through compact segment sampling. Enumerated people answered a seven-question screening test to assess whether they might have an MSI. Those who were classed as potential cases in the screening test were examined and interviewed by a physiotherapist, using a standard protocol that recorded the site, nature, cause, and severity of the MSI. People with MSI due to trauma were asked whether this trauma occurred during the 1990–1994 war or during the episodes that preceded or followed this war. Out of 8,368 people enumerated, 6,757 were available for screening and examination (80.8%). 352 people were diagnosed with an MSI (prevalence = 5.2%, 95% CI = 4.5–5.9%). 106 cases of MSI (30.6%) were classified as resulting from trauma, based on self-report and the physiotherapist's assessment. Of these, 14 people (13.2%) reported that their trauma-related MSI occurred during the 1990–1994 war, and a further 7 (6.6%) that their trauma-related MSI occurred during the violent episodes that preceded and followed the war, giving an overall prevalence of trauma-related MSI related to the 1990–1994 war of 0.3% (95% CI = 0.2–0.4%). Conclusions/Significance A decade on, the overall prevalence of MSI was relatively high in Rwanda but few cases appeared to be the result of the 1994 war or related violence.

Good point, but here’s what the article says “Europe has experienced nothing like it since World War I, and the United States not since the Civil War.”
So the title is misleading clickbait that is posted for engagement and misinformation/propaganda?
I get it… Comments below seem to play stupid in bad-faith (or just completly ignorant). It is ridicoulous to compare the “scale of trauma since ww1” with the current (relatively smal) war in ukraine. During ww2 people with disabilities were purged - how is that trauma less then what this title is alluding to?

It seems that you think something can’t be bad if there’s something else that’s worse.

You bringing up things that doesn’t even share a similar context is either plain stupid or very deliberate.

I’m voting for the latter.

By the way… You do agree that the Russian aggression against Ukraine is caused by Russia attacking Ukraine and that Russia have a deliberate strategy of killing civilians in Ukraine, right?

Ok, I guess the title is easy to misunderstand but I still don’t think it’s the blatantly untrue statement you think it is. Maybe they intentionally wrote the title in a way that is easy to misunderstand to make you read the article and that would be misleading, but if you read it, you will understand that they are talking about something very specific when they say worst traume since ww1 and not claiming it’s the worst thing ever since ww1.
It is blatently untrue and exagerated propaganda. Of course all human suffering is bad - however, it is also not a competition of who has more trauma. This is a shit article with a shit title and it should be flagged as misinformation/propaganda.