A big thanks to everyone who engaged with my recent post that looked like I was just shitting on a beloved browser. You all helped me clarify my argument somewhat, and that new slightly clearer argument is as follows:

(tl;dr: Google is the only company capable of paying to develop a cross-platform browser + rendering engine combo, and in fact pays entirely for both of the ones that exist)

Edit: here's
a little poll to gauge what you've thought about my little tirades on the future of the web
Jer Warren (@nyquildotorg)

I could never in good conscience tell people to donate to Mozilla, but I will suggest that if you disagree with me that you put your money where your mouth is. And you can [do that via this link](https://donate.mozilla.org/en-US/) 📊

Firefish Social
Google adding "DRM" to Chromium is really bad. But the fundamental reason why that is bad cannot be addressed by telling your friends to switch to [the one non-Chromium browser].

That fundamental reason is:

90% of all Mozilla funding comes directly from Google in exchange for sending users into Google's ad surveillance machine. To the tune of $450,000,000 USD per year.

Google is the only company that can afford to build a cross-platform browser engine + browser combo, and they've been effectively affording
two of them for decades.

(More)
Mozilla can't afford to compete with Google in the browser space now, while Google is paying Mozilla more money every year than they're actually spending on Firefox.

The only way more users "switching to Firefox" can increase Mozilla's revenue is if Mozilla does
more selling the eyeballs of their users than they already do. And doing that is literally the entire reason Chromium is bad in the first place.

Therefore, unless you're telling your friends to also
support Mozilla financially, telling them to switch to it will just cause more eyeball selling.
Yes, a larger market share of Firefox users would be good for the health of the web. Developers would test in it more, so fewer pages would be broken.

But that does nothing to ensure that Firefox can even exist any longer. If your objective is saving the web from Google, getting your friends' eyeballs into Mozilla's eyeball-selling machine may offset
some of the money that Google's massive yearly payment brings in. But it can never ever match it without becoming exactly the same problem you have with Chromium now.
In summary. "Just use Firefox" will do nothing.

"Pay for Firefox" may well do something. But you don't see Mozilla even offering that
🤷

Yes, you could donate to Mozilla. Have been able to for several decades. But have you ever? How many of the people you've told to "just use Firefox" have?

More people using Firefox does not mean more people donating to Firefox.
I think the biggest challenge in getting Firefox to fund itself has actually been the complicated combination of "non-profit foundation" and "corporation that builds software" setup they've been using.

It clearly doesn't work. Maybe separating those things would have better results.
There was a time when I loved Mozilla, and did donate to them. But over the last twenty years they have conclusively proved that they're incapable of managing the kind of money it takes to maintain an engine and browser that uses it.

I don't think I really need to explain that part to people, but to start with, increasing the CEO's salary (to $3 million per year), while laying people off for financial reasons, is pretty gross.

But so is building and throwing away:

An entire mobile phone operating system, multiple niche-use browsers like Firefox VR & Firefox Lite (Firefox Focus still exists meaning two actively developed Android browsers), several extension systems (requiring developers to rebuild extensions), several theming systems, a password manager, a file sharing tool, a note taking tool, a code editor, a Electron-style system that wrapped webpages as "native apps", a video chat system and I'm really fucking tired of typing now but you get the idea.
I could never in good conscience tell people to donate to Mozilla, but I will suggest that if you disagree with me that you put your money where your mouth is. And you can do that via this link
You have made me think
Fuck you, you're wrong
I'm donating at least $5 a month to prove it
Just show the results
Poll ends at .
Donate now | Donate to Mozilla

We are proudly non-profit, non-corporate and non-compromised. Thousands of people like you help us stand up for a healthy internet for all. We rely on donations to carry out our mission to keep the Web open and free. Will you give today?

Donate to Mozilla