stopthatgirl7Jul 29, 2023

Biden signs historic order moving prosecution of military sexual assault outside chain of command |

President Joe Biden on Friday ordered a historic change to the Uniform Code of Military Justice by transferring key decision-making authorities outside the military chain of command in cases of sexual assault, domestic violence, child abuse, murder and other serious crimes.

https://www.cnn.com/2023/07/28/politics/biden-executive-order-sexual-assault-military/index.html

Show threadDojanJul 29, 2023
It was in the chain of command before? Wow gee I wonder how that could possibly go wrong!
Show threadMojave

I know a soldier who got drunk and sexually assaulted a chick one night. She reports it, they run it up the chain of command, and the unit treats the case like shit. He runs fast and does a lot of push ups, so they had him deploy to Afghanistan while he was under investigation. Uh oh now the can’t investigate him. Supposedly assaults another soldier while he’s out there, but she is too scared to make a report.

A year passes, the chain of command promotes the rapist to SGT, case closed due to ‘lack of evidence’ and the chick gets discharged with PTSD. God bless 'em.

Jul 29, 2023 at 10:33amWeb
Show threadShialacJul 29, 2023
Why the fuck are these cases even handled by the military and not the regular criminal and civil courts?
Show threadRedditgeeJul 29, 2023
Playing advocate, but that’s why UCMJ exists, at all. They should prosecute all crimes under UCMJ, or none. It doesn’t make much sense to only do certain crimes under civilian courts.
Show threadI_Fart_GlitterJul 29, 2023
I mean, if UCMJ doesn’t consider prosecuting rape to be worth their time, it’s good that they’ve been relieved of that duty. Solders endure enough trauma, getting raped by those they serve with and under shouldn’t be par for the course.
Show threadgalloog1Jul 29, 2023
The civilian justice system is absolutely not better at executing justice and is arguably worse on many ways when comparing similar cases. At least the rape kits get actually tested and processed in the military.
Show threadHuxleywaswriteAug 2, 2023

I wonder if you realize you’re commenting on a reply of someone telling a story about how one want even investigated and then the rapist was promoted after doing it again.

There’s plenty to criticize in our civilian justice system, but that doesn’t mean there isn’t plenty to criticize in our military justice system. This is one of those things, the military is notoriously bad at handling sexual assault cases.

Show threadgalloog1Aug 2, 2023
I was commenting on if it is worth their time. I find it to be a wholely unjustified statement given the fact that they actually conduct justice unlike civilian juridictions. If it wasn’t worth their time, they wouldn’t be addressing it.
Show threadHuxleywaswriteAug 2, 2023

So you’ve already made up your mind and don’t care what facts and testimony is presented to you?

I hope you see the fucking irony in that.

Show threadgalloog1Aug 2, 2023

I addressed specific points. You have leveled an accusation without addressing my point. What are you expecting in response?

I have had this command authority before. I’m not going to sit here and tell you that ucmj is perfect but it’s the best we can do and it is better than the civilian sector. That should end the conversation right there. Your comments are like the pot calling the kettle black. If you have a better suggestion, why has it not been implemented yet literally anywhere?

Complaining about the way things are without a suggestion is worse than unhelpful because it increases discontent which leads to more conflict.

Thinking you know better than literal experts speaks for itself.

Show threadHuxleywaswriteAug 2, 2023

You didn’t address shit, you said ‘were better than theirs’ and left it at that.

Your word, from someone who sat in this corrupted chain of command, should be all I need to trust that you’re the best? That’s gonna be a hard fuck you from me.

Your attitude toward this is exactly why you shouldn’t have jurisdiction over it.

Show threadgalloog1Aug 3, 2023

I commented on if the accusations were worth the military’s time. It is apparently worth the military’s time more than the civilian justice system’s time.

Statement -> rebuttal

You can take your ignorant self and go fuck yourself. You don’t even know how little you know about this issue yet you opine pretty strongly about opinions you THINK I have.

While I wholely support a civilian controlled military, your attitude towards this is why civilians make horrible military governance.

Show threadHuxleywaswriteAug 3, 2023
I’m sorry I thought I’d already blocked your ignorant ass
Show threadgalloog1Aug 3, 2023
Right, don’t address my points. Just flip the table and walk away.
Show threadsnooggumsJul 29, 2023
Supposedly to hold them to a higher standard, but like with police internal affairs it is just a way to deflect attention that would make the system look bad.
Show threadStealthToadJul 29, 2023

Because the military has been fighting it for years. I remember having a SHARP class where the instructor was telling us that we didn’t want this, that civilians shouldn’t get involved in military matters and some other bullshit I can’t recall.

I was too young, dumb, and loyal to a fault to understand what was being said.