What can we do to get review threads similar to the ones on /r/Games?

https://lemmy.world/post/2213266

What can we do to get review threads similar to the ones on /r/Games? - Lemmy.world

See https://www.reddit.com/r/Games/comments/14f8jsg/final_fantasy_xvi_review_thread/ [https://www.reddit.com/r/Games/comments/14f8jsg/final_fantasy_xvi_review_thread/] for an example. I realize that they are likely mostly done by hand but I quite miss them. They were some of my favorite features on that subreddit. I suppose a script could be written to automate at least parts of it. What do you think?

I do occasionally make review threads like that one. They’re easy to do and aren’t done by hand actually, anyone can grab the template from OpenCritic.

  • Go to OpenCritic and find the game you want

  • Under “Share This Game”, click the rightmost button (Export)

  • Choose the “Reddit” export (it’s actually just markdown so it can be used anywhere)

  • And there you go, it’ll give you a template full of reviews you can copy and paste to make your own thread. Now it’s mostly a matter of cleaning up the formatting a bit and maybe removing some lesser known reviews in case there are too many (like 20+ of them)

    Remnant II | Review Thread | 80/100 OpenCritic - lemm.ee

    Game Information -------------------- Game Title: Remnant II Platforms: - PC (Jul 25, 2023) - PlayStation 5 (Jul 25, 2023) - Xbox Series X/S (Jul 25, 2023) Trailer: - Remnant 2 - Official Announcement Trailer [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8da6XwxmV30] Developer: Gunfire Games Publisher: Gearbox Publishing Review Aggregator: OpenCritic - 80 average - 92% recommended - 12 reviews [https://opencritic.com/game/15194/remnant-ii] Critic Reviews ------------- ACG [https://opencritic.com/outlet/310/acg] - Buy [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lIFd4FxQmcA] >“A huge improvement on the original with some mechanics changes that might rub prior title holders the wrong way. Performance isn’t the best but the core gameplay and loop is awesome!” ------------- AltChar [https://opencritic.com/outlet/820/altchar] - Asmir Kovacevic [https://opencritic.com/critic/9667/asmir-kovacevic] - 90 / 100 [https://www.altchar.com/reviews/remnant-2-review-aGUza6J7aEaw] >If you have a fondness for engaging shooting mechanics, visually stunning landscapes, and well-designed enemies, along with a certain level of tolerance for Souls-like games, then Remnant 2 is unquestionably the perfect game for you. ------------- But Why Tho? [https://opencritic.com/outlet/722/but-why-tho-] - Katherine Kong [https://opencritic.com/critic/9638/katherine-kong] - 9 / 10 [https://butwhytho.net/2023/07/remnant-ii-pc-review/] >Remnant II, however, manages to linger in my mind with its glow-up: memorable, impressive, and damningly fun. ------------- GameSpot [https://opencritic.com/outlet/32/gamespot] - Richard Wakeling [https://opencritic.com/critic/1425/richard-wakeling] - 7 / 10 [https://www.gamespot.com/reviews/remnant-2-review-what-the-dog-doing/1900-6418092/?ftag=CAD-01-10abi2f] >Remnant 2 builds on its predecessor to create a rewarding and unpredictable experience that’s difficult to put down. ------------- Hardcore Gamer [https://opencritic.com/outlet/23/hardcore-gamer] - Jordan Helm [https://opencritic.com/critic/890/jordan-helm] - 4 / 5 [https://hardcoregamer.com/?post_type=post&p=456030] >Building on everything that was great about the original - from enemy variety to boss design to the means by which one can customize their play-style - Remnant II just about scrapes by with a follow-up that befits the mantle of “bigger, better, bolder” in numerous ways. ------------- Saving Content [https://opencritic.com/outlet/338/saving-content] - Evan Rowe [https://opencritic.com/critic/4888/evan-rowe] - 5 / 5 [https://www.savingcontent.com/2023/07/20/remnant-2-review/] >Remnant II is a deeply imaginative, incredibly well designed game that will excite and thrill you repeatedly. It’s incredible to play with friends, and it’s an adventure unlike almost anything else I’ve ever seen, except for Remnant: From the Ashes. Remnant II builds on the template set out by its predecessor and pushes it to amazing new heights, and it is everything you could ask from a sequel and so much more. ------------- Seasoned Gaming [https://opencritic.com/outlet/451/seasoned-gaming] - Patrick Shields [https://opencritic.com/critic/8125/patrick-shields] - 8.5 / 10 [https://seasonedgaming.com/2023/07/20/review-remnant-2-remnants-of-greatness/] >I can’t get enough of Remnant 2. When I’m not playing, I’m often thinking about new upgrade paths, character builds, and play styles to explore while adventuring through Remnant 2’s engaging worlds. ------------- The Outerhaven Productions [https://opencritic.com/outlet/335/the-outerhaven-productions] - 4.5 / 5 [https://www.theouterhaven.net/2023/07/remnant-ii-review/] >Gunfire Games has taken everything it learned with Remnant From the Ashes and expanded on it in such a massive way that I don’t think it can top it. But I’m more than happy to see them try. There’s something for Remnant junkies, action RPG and Soulslike fans to enjoy, but more importantly, the game screams fun. ------------- Try Hard Guides [https://opencritic.com/outlet/855/try-hard-guides] - Christian Harrison [https://opencritic.com/critic/9149/christian-harrison] - 6.5 / 10 [https://tryhardguides.com/remnant-2-review/] >As much as I wanted to enjoy Remnant 2, I don’t think that a game should be that level of hassle just to get through the first experience it offers. It’s not a bad idea to make boss fights a little harder when more players involved, but your game has to be approachable by players or it will not make a wave among similar titles. Paired with the technical and extreme connectivity issues that we experienced during gameplay, it’s hard to recommend this game to anyone who wants to play without Google open for guides and server status checks. ------------- VideoGamer [https://opencritic.com/outlet/71/videogamer] - Alex Raisbeck [https://opencritic.com/critic/9998/alex-raisbeck] - 8 / 10 [https://www.videogamer.com/reviews/remnant-2-review/] >Remnant 2 successfully evolves on its predecessor, isolating and expanding upon the best aspects to create a cohesive and challenging shooter experience, supplemented by stunningly designed environments and a unique story system. A cooperative game at heart, its single-player campaign takes a hit, but never enough to substantially detract from the game’s successes. ------------- WhatIfGaming [https://opencritic.com/outlet/842/whatifgaming] - Ali Hashmi [https://opencritic.com/critic/8925/ali-hashmi] - 9 / 10 [https://whatifgaming.com/remnant-2-review] >Remnant 2 is one of the best co-op experiences you can have right now, and it improves on the original in every single way. Its satisfying mix of melee and ranged combat, memorable boss fights full of creativity, tons of enemy variety scattered in each biome and excellent presentation make it Gunfire Games’ best title to date. ------------- XboxEra [https://opencritic.com/outlet/758/xboxera] - Jesse Norris [https://opencritic.com/critic/7583/jesse-norris] - 7.6 / 10 [https://xboxera.com/2023/07/20/review-remnant-ii/] >Remnant II tickles greatness but falls short due to a few design choices.  It is gorgeous, plays incredibly well, and should be one of the year’s best releases.  I’m not sure if my issues with the game can be easily patched out, but I hope the devs at Gunfire Games give this one the same love the first game received over time.

    Oh, cool! I didn’t know this was already a thing. Thank you!
    Super! We will remember this one!
    You can make one and post it

    There’s nothing wrong with copying the thread to Lemmy IMO. Just do it :)

    There’s no copyright and I can’t imagine any ethical issues here.

    Be the change you want to see in the world

    Those threads were user driven. Honestly, the easiest way would be to reach out to TurboStrider and see if he had any interest in posting over here. He was always very cordial with the “old guard” (long time members that underwent a mass exodus over the last 6 months, myself included) on the mod team and has bristled a bit with the remaining team, at least at the time of my departure. It’s a lot more work than it appears and that’s why the mod team stayed far, far away from it (and the impossible to avoid optics of biases based on where various publications fell in order).

    I think the best option right now would be to post a framework thread on launch day, have a pinned post if possible or just upvote the snot out of a placeholder and have users reply to said top post with reviews as they trickle in with a copy and paste format provided at the bottom of the framework thread. Sorry if my terminology and/or lack of knowledge on what tools we have available here comes off the wrong way, I just was deeply involved in r/games for several years and old habits die hard.