Why #pedestrian #infrastructure matters (a thread):

I have to drop my car off at the shop later this week for some maintenance that requires me to leave it for an afternoon. The shop is not really withing my walking radius (especially in July), and my partner’s and my work schedules make it inconvenient for me to ask her for a ride at the time I need it. (1/12)

However! There is a bus stop less than a quarter mile from the shop that goes right by my neighborhood. If I time it right, I can get home in 15-20 minutes for free and at no bother to anyone. (It would take me ~10 to drive.) (2/12)
Unfortunately, walking the 1,191 feet from the shop to the stop in the most direct manner is…inadvisable. (3/12)
Let’s zoom in on those street crossings that Google Maps has helpfully suggested, shall we? (4/12)
The good news here is that traffic is only coming from one direction. The bad news is that there are four lanes of it, it is FAST, and people are often making last-minute lane changes to get to either Duke or Roxboro at the split. I would not cross here unless it was very early in the morning, and even then I’m not sure. (5/12)

Setting aside the suggestion to walk in the middle of oncoming traffic on Roxboro, even crossing these two lanes the sensible way is a huge problem. Again, traffic is only coming from one direction, but here it is either turning right from Roxboro, or coming straight from Duke. Which is to say, there is *always* car traffic with the right of way here.

For a pedestrian, crossing here is suicidal. (6/12)

It would be theoretically safer to cross as shown here, because you can work with the lights and you ought to have good visibility with the cars stopped at the line. However, because there are no marked crosswalks, no pedestrian signals, and no pedestrian infrastructure whatsoever, literally no driver is expecting you to be here doing this. That is incredibly dangerous. (7/12)
If you take the second option above, you can at least avoid this very inadvisable crossing at Ryan Street, where there is no crosswalk, no signal, and two lanes of fast moving traffic in each direction. The nearest designated crosswalk is nearly a quarter mile south at Horton Road, meaning a half-mile detour (double the distance you just walked from the auto shop). (8/12)
The actual way to do this, of course, is to walk down Duke to the crosswalks at Holt School Road, cross Duke, and cut through the parking lots to Roxboro and up to the bus stop. This adds about 900 feet to the walk, which is not a big deal…in the context of only needing to do it once. However… (9/12)

1) It’s worth pointing out that I have lived here many years and driven through this intersection thousands of times, and I didn’t know the way to do this without scouting it out on Google Maps first.

2) People who rely on public transit have to make these calculations every day of their lives. (10/12)

A 900-ft (approximately 5-min) detour is not a big deal for me. I’m able-bodied, and I only need to do this once. And frankly, I have the means to just call an Uber if I don’t feel like it (which I may!)

This is a position of enormous privilege. (11/12)

For someone who does this every day, these detours add up. If they’re late for work and the next bus doesn’t come for an hour, they are going to take otherwise unnecessary risks.

Effectively, this is a tax on poverty, extracted in time, energy, health, and safety. (fin)

Coda: I realize this framing could be seen as equating "transit users" with "poor people." Not my intention. Everyone should use transit if they can! (And I certainly have, though admittedly not regularly, in Durham.)

My point is that a lot of transit users do not have the luxury of choosing it.

@bullcitybrian

Great points.

I used to take a train from North County San Diego to Sorrento Valley every day for work - it took maybe 10 minutes longer, door to door, but it took a lot of stress out of my day. It did mean that I was without a vehicle at lunchtime, which created a bit of inconvenience.

There was a retail center just on the other side of the 805 from the office with a half-dozen lunch options, and the weather in San Diego should make it an obvious place to walk to get lunch - especially as parking in the retail center at lunchtime was a bit of a nightmare.

However, the crossing was a death trap with relatively high speeds and no signal for people to cross. Of the several hundred people at that office, I think fewer than a dozen of us ever walked to get lunch.

1/2

How many trip-hours for single-passenger vehicles would have been avoided if they had implemented minimal pedestrian infrastructure for the hundreds of people working in the office parks less than one mile away? How many others might have been willing to use the very nice mass transit option (SD Coaster) if the area had been more pedestrian-friendly?

Note: I haven't been to this area in 6 or 7 years, so there may have been improvements since, but all the investments I saw go in were definitely focused on vehicle traffic. (2/2)