1/ Russians serving in the military have effectively been stripped of their legal rights and serve without recourse to justice. A group of Russian lawyers say that government restrictions and the sheer volume of cases have left them effectively powerless to defend the rights of those fighting for Russia. ⬇️
2/ A 'Committee of Military Lawyers' was formed in the western Russian city of Vladimir in the autumn of 2022 to provide legal assistance to those who were being mobilised. Since then, the five women lawyers on the committee have been helping with a range of legal issues.

3/ However, in a "cry from the heart" posted to their Telegram channel on 9 July, the lawyers describe frankly the obstacles that the government and military have placed in their way. They admit that they are overwhelmed and unable to help most applicants.

Their comments are worth reviewing to highlight how the Russian state has systematically curtailed the protections of those fighting for it. They write that the situation has evolved through four phases over each of the last four seasons.

4/ In the autumn of 2022, they write, there was "general confusion (prosecutors would throw up their hands and say "we don't know how it should be"), confusion in the heads of officials and a mess on the ground." They nonetheless managed to get some things done to help their clients.

5/ The Russian government cracked down on the lawyers over the winter of 2022-23:

"Our legislators woke up, worked hard, and instead of streamlining the legal field of military affairs, they eradicated it altogether. Well, that is in general. They tightened laws aimed at suppressing any discontent in the ranks of servicemen and their relatives, untied the hands of officials in relation to prisoners sent to the front, and not only to them. People were intimidated. And so were we."

6/ " You probably don't know, but lawyers dealing with such cases are under the scrutiny of various bodies, because we are in the way."

Things continued in the same way in the spring of 2023: "We went to the courts for payments to the wounded, we wrote complaints about the lack of allowances, we tried to put things in order with the registration of servicemen, who, in fact, became phantoms in the ranks of the Armed Forces because of the mess and loss of documents, in particular."

7/ "Spring conscription began, and our help was needed there too."

Ukraine's counter-offensive in the summer of 2023 made things drastically worse.

"Summer came. And we are drowning under the flood of appeals. Their character has seriously changed. You probably know what we're talking about. Soldiers have been at the front for months. Many are missing in action. There are many prisoners and mobilised men among them. The situation at the front is very difficult, it's no secret."

8/ "And the mess since autumn hasn't gone away. It has become even worse. And we have three factors today that make it impossible to provide legal aid in the true sense of the word:

❗️ The difficult situation at the front
❗️ Closure of any information about the fighters."

9/ "❗️ Inability and inability of the bodies supervising the observance of the rights of servicemen to fulfil their duties (yesterday we received 25 complaints sent to various instances, which were never answered. These were replies and forwardings to other instances)."
10/ "The lawyers lament that "in the current circumstances, it is simply impossible to help in the legal field in many cases. ... But tell me, dear subscribers, what else can we do if your husbands, sons and brothers are thrown into battle, threatening extrajudicial reprisals? These are the appeals that are the most numerous now."

11/ "Do not expect magic from us, we do not make decisions for you and your relatives and do not give advice outside the legal field. We will always listen to you, study the situation, assess it, make every effort to resolve it, but in the end only the servicemen themselves can make certain decisions and implement them. This is war." /end

Source:
https://t.me/warlaw33/536

Комитет военных юристов

❗️Я хочу, чтобы смысл этого важного текста был понятен каждому, кто его прочитает. Для этого сначала немного предыстории: 1. Почти год мы ежедневно оказываем юридическую помощь по военным делам всем, кто к нам обратился. Осенью 2022 года объем запросов увеличился в десятки раз в связи с мобилизацией. Ситуация в правовом поле была примерно следующая: закон не успевал за действительностью, судебная практика отсутствовала, мы с вами ее формировали, общались с военкомами, общались с командирами частей, председателями ВВК и военными прокурорами. В связи со всеобщей растерянностью (прокуроры разводили руками и говорили «мы не знаем как должно быть»), сумбуром в головах должностных лиц и бардаком на местах, не смотря на то, что иногда нам казалось, что сделать ничего нельзя, мы делали. И работало. 2. К зиме 2022-2023 наши законодатели очухались, ударно поработали, и вместо того, чтобы упорядочить правовое поле по военным делам, искоренили его совсем. Ну то есть вообще. Ужесточили законы, направленные на подавление…

Telegram
@ChrisO_wiki "This is War". But it isn't, is it? "This is Kleptocracy" would be more accurate.