I think defederating Threads is a huge missed opportunity for Mastodon to grow.

Imagine interacting with their users and letting them know that: you scroll posts without ads, your timeline is in chronological order, your client doesn’t spy on you, you only see what you want and no other content is pushed to your timeline, etc…

if I was a Threads users, I would move to Mastodon as soon as I find out šŸ™‚

@andreagrandi So do I...I prefer Fosstodon's stance on it...wait and see how it shakes out, then decide. If they turn out to be a negative influence, then defederate.

@thundergod97 ā€œwe totally can’t know for sure Meta will be a negative influenceā€ are you serious ? I’ve you not heard / read anything about their products for the last 15 years ?

They’re not good guys, they never were. Open your eyes.

@andreagrandi

@Seth You can stop with putting words in my mouth.

Fosstodon fosters free and open software development. That means transparency. That means leaving things open as much as possible.

I fully expect them to be the evil corporation they have been in the last 15 years. I fully expect we will get to a point where they will have to defederate from them.

That's not the default position though. You leave it open until there's no other choice but to close it off.

@thundergod97 wow i’m really sorry i dared ā€œtranslateā€ your ā€œIf they turn out to be a negative influenceā€ in a sarcastic ā€œwe totally can’t know for sure Meta will be a negative influenceā€

to me both those sentences have the same meaning but i might have misunderstood your initial statement.

tbh i don’t understand the point of ā€œleave it open until there’s no other choiceā€ when you ā€œfully expect them to be the evil corporation they have been the last 15 yearsā€

i’m not advocating for a Minority Report situation where we lock people before they even had the idea of doing something wrong. I’m just saying that it’s a safer move to place a lock on your door or your parked bike, and eventually don’t use it / remove it if your neighboorhood is trustworthy enough than wait to see if your house has been burgled or your bike stolen before considering locking it.

Especially when we know how said bad faith actor has been acting for 15 years and keep acting today.

@thundergod97 anyway, feel free to act like you wish, i’m not really asking you to do otherwise. I’m just stating that i find it foolish and explaining why, so people reading this thread might make their opinion on the topic. :)
@thundergod97 @Seth sounds naive. you leave it open until there is nothing left to close sounds more plausible