Killing Community - Beehaw

Great writing on the current Reddit saga. The author put down in words a lot of things in my mind I couldn’t find the right words.

Yeah, I keep saying this to people when they worry about fragmentation. Like it's important to have all the Baseball fans in the same Baseball forum under one big banner.

No, that's not better, that's worse. What you want is a thousand interconnected forums with 100 people each, not a forum with 100,000 people.

How is community engagement better in a interconnected forum compared to a single forum consisting of all the participants? I'm asking out of ignorance

How would cross community discussions take place?

to start with, ive had more vibrant, long and interesting conversations more often on a site of 300-3,000 as opposed to a sub with millions.
I agree but I think the days of phpbb forums are unfortunately over. I don't think people will switch back to them.
id disagree, this dynamic exists on discord with thousands of communities and hundred's of redundant servers. What you are seeing as "people" is mostly "folks Stockholmed by reddit"