"On being asked what made the LMB such a remarkable place, Max answered: ‘Creativity in science, as in art [referring to the Renaissance in Florence], cannot be organised. It arises spontaneously from individual talent. Well-run laboratories can foster it, but hierarchical organisations, inflexible bureaucratic rules, and mountains of futile paperwork can kill it. Discoveries cannot be planned, they pop up, like Puck, in unexpected corners.’"

From Daniela Rhodes' 2002 piece on #MaxPerutz
https://www.embopress.org/doi/full/10.1093/embo-reports/kvf103

#academia #MaxPerutz #MRCLMB #podcast

Every time I fill in a reimbursement form for what amounts to pennies, articulate a justification or a dispensation for a purchase, write half a dozen emails for something that costs £70 (not counting the time of those involved), or write a "PDR" for a lab member who is leaving in a couple months, or do another compulsory training course on a topic I could have written a scholarly paper about it myself, I think of #MaxPerutz's statement above.

The academic scientific enterprise could be organised so much more effectively. Start by evaluating scientists by what they have done, not what they will do; the rest unfolds from that and leads to enormous savings in time (for scientists) and money (far less admin costs).

Government, funding bodies, are you listening? Are you ready to let go, and evaluate scientists on past work, and save hundreds of millions in the process? Or better yet, reallocate them to science itself for an even bigger impact?

#academia

@albertcardona @albertcardona all for encouraging creative science. But doesn’t “evaluate scientists based on past work” entrench a rich-get-richer system?

@cian

Surely there ought to be a ramp in system alongside the evaluation of established labs? Obviously for early career scientists, but also for others.

Evaluating on past work means, to me, to trust scientists to do sensible work and to cross-check each other. To fund them and then evaluate on what they’ve done, rather than micromanaging every one of their daily actions. The latter is very time wasteful, yet it pretty closely represents the current system.

@albertcardona @cian

I'm getting quite fond of the idea of reasonable baseline funding. If you hire people to do research, give them at least some means to do it.

@BorisBarbour @albertcardona @cian it boggles my mind that this isn't just universally agreed.