All of the posts on Mastodon about how the Blue Sky team was silly for releasing a social media network in 2023 without blocking and moderation, even in private beta, and that the Blue Sky team should have known what would happen...

...are being written on Mastodon: a social media platform that in 2023, still doesn't take into account that Black users face a disproportionate amount of very specific types of abuse, and is missing key features that would make the Black population safer. 🙂🙃

It really is the social media equivalent of white folks telling Black folks that Boston is less racist than the South, and completely ignoring any Black folk that live in Boston or anywhere else in the US trying to talk about what their real, lived, experiences have been.

Many Mastodon users are just completely convinced of the superiority of their moderation philosophy, and they are as happy to ignore the few Black Fedi users in 2023 as they were in 2017.

I'm not interested in having Fedi 'splained to me. I'm just saying why more Black folk are on BlueSky:

1. It should be almost impossible for a new, non-technical user to onboard onto the Fediverse and accidentally join a server where they will receive racist death threats.

2. It should not be possible for racists to reply to a Black user's post with hateful gore images, without other users on the server knowing it.

3. It should be easy for a new admin to default into a safe, general denylist.

This isn't an exhaustive list, but these 3 are fairly straightforward ones. And they're not new. You can seriously find Black users asking for these going back to 2017.

Even trying to discuss these often results in:
* You just don't know how the Fediverse works!
* Shared deny lists can be abused, so let's never have them!
* You just love Twitter! You want quote tweets! You want Elon to hurt you again!

So Black Fediverse users tend to self-select into one of a few buckets:

1) Kinda Stubborn (AKA, this isn't my 1st racism): Willing to stay until things improve. People like me, @BlackAzizAnansi etc.

2) Super Stubborn (AKA, I will change you!): Willing to stay and fight the tide of the whole Fediverse for as long as it takes to fix things. @Are0h etc.

3) Normal People (AKA, life is too short): They just leave the Fediverse. This is most Black folk.

The "3s" are going from Twitter to BlueSky.🤷🏿‍♂️

@BlackAzizAnansi @Are0h

If you take one thing from my little thread here it's this: Black people don't leave the fediverse because of openly racist people.

Just like Black people don't leave Boston or San Francisco because of the openly racist people. There are openly racist people everywhere.🤷🏿‍♂️

Black people leave the fediverse, Boston, and San Francisco, because of the behavior of the supposed "non-racist" people. The combination of extreme racism, and denial of its existence, is too much.

@mekkaokereke @BlackAzizAnansi @Are0h Honest question: How can “normal non-racist” people help? I’m just an ordinary mastodon user, not involved in maintaining any mastodon instance. I agree that not calling out racism when you see it is (almost) as bad as being racist. But as a non black person, I don’t see much of it on mastodon.
@rjschutten Dude. If a black person tells you the "non-racist" white people who deny the presence of racism on Mastodon as the main reason black people would leave, replying by saying "I don't see it" is at best tone deaf. If you don't see racism on Mastodon, then you're not paying attention - to start, all you have to do is notice how much tone policing there is in these parts. The Fedi reeks of it.
@jf_718 OK maybe I am tone deaf & you can call me out for it. I do see all kinds of mean behavior on mastodon, but generally not against black people (doesn’t mean it’s not there). That does probably mean I don’t interact enough with black people to see it. I follow @mekkaokereke to learn & find his posts very eye opening.
@rjschutten When the Twitter Migration started last April and until the fall, it was a lot more obvious as new arrivals who are black kept getting harassed anytime they noted some of the drawbacks of the platform. Lots of paternalistic "this is how it's done here" from an imagined position of greater knowledge and authority. Black women had it even worse, as white men and white women (cis and trans) berated them for doing Mastodon "wrong".
@jf_718 @rjschutten I don't get it. Are we calling it racist when people argue with someone on an unrelated topic and that someone happens to be black?
I am rarely on fedi, so I haven't personally witnessed it tbf. Were slurs thrown around?
@jf_718 @rjschutten @CanisMajoris
Who on this thread said it was racist to argue with someone just bc the other person is Black? If there, I missed that.
If you were on fedi more you would see plenty of denial, micro-aggressions, etc. Just as if you lived in/near Boston and paid a bit of attention (can testify to this). With respect, you may want to think about your own post here as an example.
Slurs are overt racism, so not really main topic of thread.
@Katma @jf_718 @rjschutten How is my post an example? (Also, as I said, I spend months off fedi, so perhaps not the most up to date on events)

@CanisMajoris @Katma @rjschutten go read about microaggressions and know that they are very common on most social media including Mastodon - notably when they are used against black people, the group most targeted by these attacks by white people. If many are saying that this is a real issue, you not noticing only means you weren't paying attention. Start paying attention.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microaggression

Microaggression - Wikipedia

@jf_718 @Katma @rjschutten I predict this conversation will go around in circles. We'll just grate each others nerves needlessly, so I wish you all a nice day and all the best.