“This state” takes ten characters; “Nevada” takes six.

This is a forward reference headline, which goes out of its way to conceal what the corresponding story says.

It’s a consequence of click-based advertising and of course it makes our information streams less useful. The practice started among clickbait junk websites but has spread to CNN, the Washington Post, the New York Times, and others.

@ct_bergstrom …and, of course, medical journals that will not allow articles to titles to report the results of the study…
@iwashyna Interesting. For the last decade or so I’ve tried to make sure that my article titles state my main result. Are there systemic pressures against this?

@ct_bergstrom

Yes, at several high very prominent journals I have been told exactly the opposite: to highlight the question not the result. It annoys me.

Happy to discuss specifics via email

@ct_bergstrom @iwashyna
The editors at Physical Review want the result in the title: “Titles should be concise and informative, clearly stating the main findings of the manuscript.”

https://journals.aps.org/prl/authors

Information for Authors

Physical Review Letters