I don't think people are realising the danger the Fediverse is in.

The only thing stopping corporations and VCs taking over this place is that the Fediverse is spread out on many different servers, which makes it very difficult to purchase.

If most of the Fediverse ends up on mastodon.social, which is now a strong possibility, there will be nothing to stop most of it being sold to Musk or Zuckerberg or whoever.

The bigger mastodon.social becomes, the more likely a buyout is to happen.

(1/4)

Here's what Eugen Rochko's Mastodon gGmbH organisation now controls:

-The Mastodon server software & API (though the current version is FOSS)
-The mastodon.social server, which has 1 in 7 of all Fediverse users
-The official Mastodon apps, now telling people to just sign up on mastodon.social
-The official website at joinmastodon.org
-The trademark for the word "mastodon", which lets them dictate terms to any server which uses it

This is a tempting package for any potential buyers.

(2/4)

The trademark alone gives Mastodon gGmbH huge power, it lets them tell any server using the word "mastodon" in its domain name what software or forks it can use.

And it's getting worse. Mastodon gGmbH is now making official apps which direct people to sign up on mastodon.social instead of a random trusted server or choice of trusted servers.

The more people sign up on mastodon.social, the more tempting Mastodon gGmbH becomes as a takeover target.

(3/4)

With all that in mind, here's a suggestion:

➡️ *IF* mastodon.social becomes more than 50% of the Fediverse, either by total users or monthly active users, the rest of us should defederate it.

Sticking with mastodon.social because "that's where the people are" is pointless. Centralised growth will simply cause the governance problems we've seen on Twitter and Facebook to be replicated on here.

Growth has to be decentralised in order to protect the independence of all Fedi servers.

(4/4)

@feditips How do I switch servers? How do I find a suitable server for me?
@Crookedlilhouse @feditips the fedi tips website contains information on how to switch, and there is a list of servers on https://joinmastodon.org (Mastodon servers only) and https://fedi.garden
Mastodon - Decentralized social media

Learn more about Mastodon, the radically different, free and open-source decentralized social media platform.

@Crookedlilhouse @feditips fedi.directory oops

that's for accounts to follow, can't remember the one was for picking a server

@experiencersinternational @Crookedlilhouse @feditips

Came across this one the other day. Not perfect, but very populated and groups in languages and has a few other parameters you can fiddle with to see if you find something tempting.

https://www.comeetie.fr/galerie/mapstodon/

Personally, I have chosen a server in my own country to call home - because then it is much easier to give some financial support through reliable channels if needed.

Mapstodon

@MaryPot @Crookedlilhouse @feditips mastodonapp.uk is literally the only UK one that would serve me lol if I was going for region

@MaryPot @Crookedlilhouse @feditips fediverse observer was actually a heck of a lot better for more local stuff

idk if that's just the hosting servers though

@experiencersinternational @Crookedlilhouse @feditips

If you mean instances - they are both official mastodon instances.

@experiencersinternational @MaryPot @Crookedlilhouse @feditips

That's not true. There are quite a few geographic #FediVerse sites for the U.K., ranging from Glasgow.Social through Mastodon.Scot to Toot.Wales. And those are the big ones. There are further smaller ones like Mastodon.London and Dorset.Social, and more that I won't name here because I know that they are one person hobby outfits and don't need the pressure.

If you want places to look for places, go to https://hueyy.github.io/awesome-mastodon/#server-lists

Awesome Mastodon

Up-to-date and curated list of awesome Mastodon-related stuff!

awesome-mastodon

@JdeBP @experiencersinternational @MaryPot @Crookedlilhouse @feditips

Due to the deteriorating legal environment in the #UK, I'd pre-emptively select an #instance in the #EU (though not in #Poland or #Hungary, possibly not #Italy due to the #neofascist #PM, #Meloni), because of the Comunity-law backed #GDPDR Directive.

#Ireland might be a native-language choice.

@HistoPol @experiencersinternational @MaryPot @Crookedlilhouse @feditips

Interestingly, a small number of U.K.-looking instances are not, and might be the very things that you'd want.

Mastodon.London is hosted in Germany.

Mastodon.Org.UK is in the Netherlands, according to
@xvilo's blurb.

I'm not sure about Mastodon.UK.Com. It claims to be U.K.-hosted, but the about page says that French/German law applies. No clue from @root's user profile.

@JdeBP @HistoPol @experiencersinternational @MaryPot @Crookedlilhouse @feditips @root

Thats correct, mastodon.org.uk is hosted at @transip which is located in the Netherlands 

@JdeBP @experiencersinternational @MaryPot @Crookedlilhouse @feditips @xvilo @root

I think we might have to differentiate a bit.

I have not registered a URL in quite a while, but the owner or administrator of a country Top-Level Domain is usually a government agency or a government-appointed firm.
That organization could exert pressure on the URL "tenant", i.e. the person owning the (temporary) right of...

@JdeBP @experiencersinternational @MaryPot @Crookedlilhouse @feditips @xvilo @root

...use. Due to this, I, personally, would avoid any #TLD from a none-#EU country.
(I admit that as of today, this is overly cautious, but I am taking a worst-case scenario approach.)

As a second step, I have been told that the laws of the country where the server is physically based, are chiefly relevant.

However, paying up...

@JdeBP @experiencersinternational @MaryPot @Crookedlilhouse @feditips @xvilo @root

...the remaining rent/ hosting space for the (usually) year, I'd hazards a guess that most hosing companies would let you leave right away, as they can re-let your space on the server.

My point being that there also is the (latent) risk of an instance owner switching the provider and thus possibly the country, too.

However, I...

@JdeBP @experiencersinternational @MaryPot @Crookedlilhouse @feditips @xvilo @root

...pretty much doubt that any sensible instance-owner would leave the #GDPDR area, if based there initially, at this point, as this might entail a breech of contract with its users.

On the other hand, if the discussed directive for chat control comes into force, #Switzerland might be an option.

Curious about your ideas and the...

@experiencersinternational @Crookedlilhouse @feditips You can actually have accounts on multiple servers. Many clients offer support for this kind of environment.

@Crookedlilhouse @feditips
After a quick google search, here is a step-by-step guide on how to switch servers: https://nerdschalk.com/change-or-switch-servers-on-mastodon-step-by-step-guide/

If you want to find a server, https://instances.social has basically all of them, and at https://wehavecookies.social we always welcome new users.

Change or Switch servers on Mastodon: Step-by-step guide

As Twitter undergoes recent changes, many users have been looking for alternatives. And Mastodon has been at the top of…

Nerd's Chalk
@BentiGorlich @Crookedlilhouse @feditips thank you. I am trying to find one that I can move to. I hope I will able to keep all my friends☺️
@kcsorenby @Crookedlilhouse @feditips
As far as I know it should work realatively flawlessly. You should keep all your followers and follows. The only thing thats definatly lost are your posts. They will not move
@BentiGorlich @Crookedlilhouse @feditips so crazy question .., but is there no way to save them somewhere?
@kcsorenby @Crookedlilhouse @feditips
Well, they remain on your old account if you don't delete it
@Crookedlilhouse @feditips I don’t have a link right this second but fedi tips has done a tutorial on migrating before. As for finding a suitable server, I’d ask around. I personally found my current home and my alt homes through just talking to people I liked and seeing what alternatives to Mastodon were like. At this point, Akkoma and Calckey are my social media of choice and I wouldn’t go back to Mastodon anyway.

@Crookedlilhouse @feditips

Hello!

There are a collection of servers on https://joinmastodon.org/servers, also on https://instances.social as well as on https://fedi.garden/

My server is also open, but mainly for people living in Sweden.

Servers

Find where to sign up for the decentralized social network Mastodon.

@jens @Crookedlilhouse @feditips how much does it cost to run a server?

@yassinelanda @jens @Crookedlilhouse @feditips It very much depends on the number of users and how federated the instance is going to be (both effect the amount of traffic).

There are Mastodon hosting servers where you pay them to host you (only some of them are accepting new people). Searching them can give a good idea of the general costs involved.

The minimum costs seems to be around the 6 euro range. Can be cheaper if you rent a server instead of using a hosting service.

@yassinelanda @Crookedlilhouse @feditips

It very much depends on your setup and resources. If you’re renting a virtual device there’s going to be increasing costs as your server grows, but if you own your hardware and use existing internet connections then that cost could be less.

It’s also what your aim is. Should it be a small server for you and maybe some friends? Or is it a general server for thousands of people? That will affect the cost.

Mastodon — Migration: How to change your instance / server (and why)

The choice of your “home instance” does matter. While you can “chose ANY server” to start with #Mastodon and enter the #fediverse some care & diligence during a #migration is advised... (also valid for #twittermigration)

Medium
@Crookedlilhouse @feditips You've already gotten advice about how to switch, but you could also look through the people you follow to see if any servers jump out as already hosting a lot of people who post things that interest you. It's nice to have a Local timeline that you enjoy. Good luck!
@Crookedlilhouse @feditips
To answer your second question first, look around at servers of people you follow or see on your timeline. If that doesn't get results, check the federated timeline. Or try asking around if you're looking for a particular kind of instances.
Once you find a suitable instance, just make an account there. The tools to migrate your follows and followers should be in the settings.
@Crookedlilhouse @feditips You're welcome to check out oddballs.vip to see if it's a good fit for you. This instance is very small, but for some, that might be exactly what's needed.

@Crookedlilhouse @feditips
from https://universeodon.com/@Gargron@mastodon.social/103393780276051792

How to migrate from one Mastodon server to another without losing followers:

1. Sign up on new server
2. On NEW server: Go to Account -> Moving FROM another account
3. Enter old account's handle
4. On OLD server: Go to Account -> Moving TO another account
5. Enter new account's handle and submit

Eugen Rochko (@[email protected])

How to migrate from one Mastodon server to another without losing followers: 1. Sign up on new server 2. On NEW server: Go to Account -> Moving FROM another account 3. Enter old account's handle 4. On OLD server: Go to Account -> Moving TO another account 5. Enter new account's handle and submit #YoMigroaMastodon

Mastodon
@Crookedlilhouse @feditips you create an account on another server, and indicate in your old account that you have moved there (so people following your old account will follow your new account). It’s in the parameters of your account.

For choosing another server, some servers tend to be dedicated to hobbies, so checking the description and local timeline of those servers can help. Also check the instance of people you follow. If many comes from the same instance (excluding your current instance), then you could try to move to that instance. A way to check the servers to avoid is to read the list of moderated instances of your current instance. Those listed are usually instances you don’t want to move on.
@Crookedlilhouse @feditips Fox : The official website as a tool to find a server : https://joinmastodon.org/servers
( It still favor mastodon.social but I highly suggest adding some search criteria )
Servers

Find where to sign up for the decentralized social network Mastodon.

@feditips But then nothing else really changes outside of that. He still owns the trademarks. The official apps still get people signing up on m.s preferentially. m.s becomes another corporate silo.

Sure, the rest of us would be rid of mastodon.social, but if that instance is really that big then all we've done is turn them into another birbsite, and then there's the rest of us.

Defederation isn't as big a threat as it sounds, because if m.s is that big, it's self sustaining. It doesn't actually need the rest of the Fediverse.

@drwho but that's good for the rest of us because we can escape without being bought
@drwho @feditips
I would actually argue that it doesn't need the rest already...
I mean they have 200k active users...
@feditips

Thank you for taking the time to explain all of this, and so well.
How do we get out of this mess?
Sounds like the Mastodon Migration events need to steer people to other instances.
🤔
@feditips ”We had to burn down the village to save it” never goes out of vogue, huh?
@donw mastodon.social isn't the whole village. and hopefully it will never be. it's freakishly large, but it won't kill the entirety of the Fediverse if there was a mass defederation from it
@salarua @donw It would cause a number of "islands" to appear between instances due to them removing mastondon.social, and another set of instances who defederate others for defederating mastodon.social. It would effectively create random blackholes in a decentralized network, because of a centralized admin of instances decision.
@mrhamel @salarua I don’t think I would hazard to guess exactly what would happen. But it certainly feels like saying “I am concerned that this thing would lead to a bad situation” and then deciding to react by guaranteeing a bad situation.
@mrhamel @donw mastodon.social isn't the crux of the Fediverse. if mastodon.social were to suddenly disappear, nothing would change, because instances, if they don't federate directly with each other, share *dozens* of other federated instances in common
@donw @feditips this feels more like “we left our burning village, so we’re saving it by burning your village down”
@stevencworlds or maybe "we're worried about how vulnerable to flame you've made the village so we're gonna set a whole lot of fires.” It's not a perfect metaphor but it seemed like an appropriate quip to someone suggesting that the solution to a server becoming too big a percentage of the network is to make it an even bigger percentage of the network.

@donw @feditips

We have to kick out the troublemakers.
Every single time they try to impose their rules on us.

Because there will always people like you, who blame us for starting the fire.

@donw @feditips wow, such absolutely bizzare equation youre trying to set here.

@feditips Respectfully, I am not sure this would have the effect you desire.

If the few try to silence the many, this often fails and they are in turn silenced. Witness the myriad open source projects that decide to fork and then simply die from lack of contributors.

@feditips
When I joined, I spent half an hour trying to find a server that suited me and couldn't find one. That's why I chose social.
If choosing a server doesn't become much simpler, there is no way the direction will change.