UK Salary nonsense is raising its head again. The UK Treasury is trying to find a Head of Cyber Security for UK£55k. That's.... well... it's.....

I have no words.

Cost of living is definitely a thing, which seems to confuse a lot of US people when they see UK salaries. In *very general* terms, getting £100k is similar to getting US$200k.

But even so, this is terrible.

Yes, I am simplifying but, *most* people in the UK on £100k a year will have a lifestyle similar to, if not better than, most people in the US living on US$200k a year.

And, yes, you will absolutely find a lot of exceptions to that. Well done.

But this is a different problem. It is a senior role, whatever LinkedIn says. It needs someone to be in the most expensive city in the country (at least some of the time) and it needs them to have the knowledge & experience to defend a Critical National Infrastructure target.

It is a Civil Service role, so the current crazy thinking about "overpaid civil servants" and our weird government obsession with cutting all public-paid salaries except their own has an impact.

But this is a significant problem. It really is.

If they have any competent staff left, this needs to be on the Risk Register in BIG letters as a significant, but complex, risk.

For a start, hiring. Who can you hire? Anyone with the skills & knowledge for this role can get 2-3x as much with almost no effort.

I mean, I got more than this for a mid-senior government role with no civilian-world experience 14 years ago.

Whoever they hire for this role is LIKELY to have bluffed something. Or they are going to bounce & just want it for a year or two to improve their CV.

That's a bit of a red flag though, as it means they don't have a strong enough CV to get a similar role... So they either messed up massively somewhere or don't have the knowledge/experience to do the job.

Back to being a bluffer.

The second risk is more financial. If Criminal Gang X want to get someone "inside" the treasury, this makes it pretty obvious that they are dirt cheap.

I am not saying people do not have morals, but if you are senior career, flat sharing with students and eating pot noodles each day and walking to work because your salary won't cover your rent *&* food *&* travel, then a criminal who offers you £100k to look the other way, is a very, very different proposition.

Why spend money buying possibly valid creds from the DarkWeb when you can just offer the Head of Security a decent meal...

I really do wish the best to whoever gets this job but the main risk (IMHO) is that if they won't pay a decent salary for the HEAD, then your staff are underpaid, undertrained, lacking in skill or experience and your security budget will be pocket money. #infosec #cybersecurity #treasury #security

@tazwake
1/5
There's a strong correlation between income inequality, subpar wages for public servants, and public corruption.

The movie "The Big Short", based on a Michael Lewis semi-fictional novel, did a decent job of explaining how underpaid civil servants contributed to the 2008 financial crisis.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Big_Short_(film)

So did Matt Damon's documentary "Inside Job".

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inside_Job_(2010_film)

Consequences:
1. Revolving door
Back & forth hiring between public agencies & private ...
2/5

The Big Short (film) - Wikipedia

2/5
... businesses creates long term conflicts of interest.

Conflicts of interest as seen in oil lawyer Jeffrey Clark & the Jan 6 coup.

And Koch's Federalist Society lawyers on the Supreme Court.
And public policy advisors with their stupid "trickle down" economic theories.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trickle-down_economics

2. Looted national treasuries & impoverishment
Public corruption siphons taxpayer dollars out of the local economy & into Swiss & American banks. It permits the ...

3/5

Trickle-down economics - Wikipedia

3/5
... looting of national treasuries to fund genocidal wars on Ukraine & Yemen.

https://www.newstatesman.com/business/economics/2022/03/our-addiction-to-oil-has-paid-for-putins-war

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/bank-scandal-2020-2-trillion-transaction-suspected-illegal-activity-money-laundering/

https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/most-corrupt-countries

3. Public Tolerance for Public Corruption
Countries with high corruption create public expectations that an underpaid official will make up the shortfall in bribes & extortion.

https://www.chicagotribune.com/la-ed-gifts-20160829-snap-story.html

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baksheesh

https://academic.oup.com/book/35304
4. Failed States
Countries with high corruption create failed states. Crisis go ...

4/5

Our addiction to oil has paid for Putin’s war

High oil prices and the West's failure to diversify its energy mix have bankrolled a tyrannical regime.

New Statesman

4/5
... unresolved. Corrupt states cannot cope with climate change for example.

https://www.cfr.org/in-brief/lebanon-failed-state-heres-what-numbers-say

https://www.ptfund.org/corruption-as-an-indicator-of-a-failed-state/

5. Income inequality worsens
Another consequence of an underpaid public service is that only the independently wealthy can afford the opportunity costs of holding public office or gain entry to high profile employment.

Access to such high profile employment limits perspectives on solutions and leads to foolishness like Powell using interest rates to curb ...
5/5

Is Lebanon a Failed State? Here’s What the Numbers Say.

The August explosions in Beirut were the latest in a series of man-made disasters that have led some experts to say Lebanon is becoming a failed state.

Council on Foreign Relations

5/5
... greed, corporate price gouging, stock buybacks, exorbitant management compensation schemes.

It tends to fill the public service with nepotism hires and no-work/no-show patronage appointments. It results in budget overruns and shoddily run public projects from "consultancy fees".

https://thehill.com/opinion/finance/387537-unpaid-internships-unfairly-favor-the-wealthy/

https://www.mercurynews.com/2022/06/29/fraud-san-jose-fremont-home-develop-cost-sec-silicon-sage-real-estate/

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/No-show_job#:~:text=A%20no%2Dshow%20job%20is,of%20political%20or%20corporate%20corruption.

https://www.salon.com/2021/05/15/matt-gaetz-gave-escort-no-show-government-job-report_partner/

Unpaid internships unfairly favor the wealthy

The notion that students should have to forgo pay and incur additional debt to gain work experience is ludicrous.

The Hill
@Npars01 no fucking shit, as most work the summer to cover living cost the next semesters