Black cops can be racist too. That's the takeaway from that brutal murder. As with gun violence, #police #racism is a systemic issue. It cannot be solved by merely convicting murderous cops. It will happen again and again.

1) We fix the issue of police murders at the time a cop is hired, by screening out the sociopaths and racists and domestic abusers. (Up to 40% incidence of DV among cops...) There are reliable psych tests for determining the narcissistic, power-hungry personality type. Law enforcement is a *service profession* and must never be allowed to become a private power trip.

2) The workplace culture of police departments must have zero tolerance for racism and sexism. No jokes, no banter, no social media posts that glorify any of those things, or disparage any race or gender. No slurs by any police officer. Fireable offense.

3) Where malice or negligence is proven, pay wrongful death judgments out of police retirement funds. So that any settlements hit all cops in the pocketbook. That builds peer pressure for curtailing brutal behavior.

4) Go beyond a typical corporate HR department and have an active internal affairs investigation of any bullying or harassment complaints. Want a badge and a gun as a taxpayer employee? Prove you represent all citizens equally.

5) Limit police unions to collective bargaining action only. No more legal defense for corrupt cops. They can take their chances with public defenders.

6) Institute an equivalent to the Hippocratic oath for cops i.e. "first, do no harm." Make it a point of professional honor and loyalty that the job is to protect citizens, and de-escalate violence. Make it clear in the oath that mistreating any suspect is a failure, and a crime.

7) Stop producing TV shows that glorify violent / paramilitary behavior by cops, as "effective," or continuing without punishment. (Like Mayor of Kingstown, to cite one among many...)

If we don't implement sweeping police reform, the killings will continue.

#tyrenichols

@sean I’ve seen many people make demands for police reform. Sometimes it’s totally unreasonable and therefore unrealistic. I think your calls here are more reasonable than most and therefore more plausible.
@sean The police have become a paramilitary unit, but without formal rules of engagement. The US Military has rules of engagement for interactions with both combatants and non-combatants. They are know and published, and there are consequences for even the smallest infraction. There are essentially no rules of engagement for the police. Because they want to be paramilitary when they want and “protect and serve” when they’re caught.

@M_C_B52

Explicit rules of engagement should be a top target of police reform. Great point!

@sean
These are all great ideas. Much better than just "abolish the police." I don't want criminals and criminal institutions to be able to run rampant, which is what would happen if we abolish police altogether. Serious reforms are needed, though and this list is a good start.

@sean These are all reasonable CTAs and could indeed be reasonably instituted. Unfortunately, many of these ideas have been tried to limited success.

For example, zero tolerance policies have had some positive results until the next election and/or appointment of leadership... and then it backslides.

Internal affairs are a good idea and indeed have positive outcomes but clearly such hasn't lead to sweeping changes in the past. I doubt it will in the future. Perhaps, making it a federal program? Not sure that would be legal for state-run policing.

Juries also keep acquitting police officers. Yes, there have been some notable guilty verdicts, but only when there's been clear, unambiguous video evidence and a huge public outcry and even then it's not enough.

Paying judgments out of police retirements funds, this an interesting idea. It'd be problematic if the plaintiff wanted to cash out early, particularly if it's a pension. Dunno.

My view is that we need to create a new, parallel institution that is _service_ based, that you mentioned. And then significantly scale back the current corrupt institution. I don't think you can fix something so fundamentally broken.

@sean Those are interesting points. I don't know anything about policing, so I can't comment on how realistic these are. But I like that you're throwing out ideas that focus on keeping police because we do need them.
@sean in fact I wonder if Black cops have to be even more extreme to prove themselves to a white supremacist organization. Because their loyalty and participation in the system is always in question, in a way it is not as much for white police. Maybe this is the result. I’m not trying to excuse anything. As an Asian American, the minority most accused (&rightly) of buying in to the system, I have gotten pressure to buy in my whole life. That’s probably why it came to my mind.