Happy #BlackHistoryMonth !

Q: Why are there not more Black computer science grads? Or... any STEM grads for that matter?

A: Lots of systemic racism reasons, but one of the biggest ones is college sports. Changing the college sports model will increase Black college graduates by *millions* of people over 10 years. Seriously. It's one of the biggest levers for grad rates.

Let me explain why, and why I was part of the group that sponsored the California Name, Image, and Likeness bill.

1/N

The first thing to understand is that in the USA, 60% of all Black men in college will drop out.😢

The primary reason for dropping out is not grades. It is financial hardship. This is true for students of all races. Not all poor students are Black, but in the US, most Black college students are poor.

You can ask a US college student 2 questions:
1) Are you rich?
2) Is your family rich?

If the answers are "No" and "No," there is a very good chance that this student will not graduate college.

The "inciting incident" that triggers the student to drop out, is usually an unexpected expense of less than $4000. This could be car trouble, medical bill, childcare, or some other emergency.

CS professors at any school with lots of Black students will confirm: The Black students that graduate with Computer science degrees are not necessarily the best CS students at the University. They are the best of the 40% that survived the economic hardship trap.

It is a harsh and unforgiving filter.

Removing economic hardship as a factor in dropping out, would almost double the US Black college graduation rate. But how to do that? Hold that thought and let's talk about sports economics.

The NBA makes revenue through ticket sales, sponsorship deals (Official pizza of the NBA!), Apparel licensing (Official NBA Jersey!), And selling TV broadcast rights. Of this revenue, the league must pay ~50% to players.

If you add up LeBron's and every other NBA player's pay, it's ~50% of $10 billion USD.

The NFL pays ~50% of its $18B revenue to players.

The NHL pays ~50% of its $2.5B revenue to players.

Now for my European friends, take the revenue of the English Premiere League. Add that to the revenue of the Bundesliga, and add that to the revenue of La Liga. US college sports generate more revenue than those European soccer leagues... combined.🤯

Somewhere between $18B and $20B depending on who's doing the math.

Almost all of this revenue is generated from football and basketball TV deals

One TV deal, for one sport (football), for one sub league, of only ~12 schools, is over a $1B a year of college sports revenue:

https://theathletic.com/3520740/2022/08/18/big-ten-college-football-tv-rights/

But players don't see any of that $9B. In the US, it is illegal to pay these mostly Black, mostly poor, college players. 🙃

The players get "athletic scholarships" instead. The sum total of which, comes to less than 2% of league revenues.

The "student athletes" (read: employees), don't even get workers compensation if they're injured.

With Big Ten’s new deal, here’s what college football will look like on TV for next decade

Everything you need to know about what the college football TV landscape looks like for the next decade.

The Athletic

But it gets worse.

Not only does the NCAA prohibit schools from paying players, the students are forbidden from paying themselves!

If your kid is in college, and they're hungry, I can buy them a $5 taco and bag of chips. Unless they are a college athlete. In which case me even buying them a $5 lunch is a violation, and they could lose their scholarship.🤡

The students are kept in artificial poverty, because they're easier to control, and dependent on the "gift" of an athletic scholarship.

But athletes like LeBron and Steph don't just make money by being paid by the NBA. They also get sponsorship deals, and can have other jobs (sports analyst, run sports camps, etc).

The Name, Image, and Likeness bill, says that colleges in California cannot restrict kids from having sponsorship opportunities. You don't have to pay the athletes. But you can't stop the athletes from paying themselves. 👍🏿

We did California first, for the same reason that environmentalists target California emissions standards first. California is big enough that car manufacturers can't ignore the state (e.g. Camry not available in California). And they're not going to make two different models of every car for the USA (e.g. California Camry vs normal Camry). So every car sold in the US, ends up meeting the stricter California standard. 👍🏿

And some states' standards are just copied off of California's homework.🤷🏿‍♂️

But again, what do rich athletes have to do with millions of Black college graduates? Millions of people don't play sports?

In the US, there is a "graduation halo" around Black athletes. 🤯

But it makes sense:

If your cousin plays for the Warriors, they are not letting you drop out of MIT just because you can't afford an unexpected $4000.

If your uncle plays for the Raiders, they're not letting you miss a semester sitting falsely accused in jail, because you can't afford bail.

How would the US change if we could transfer ~$9B a year to some of its poorest, most vulnerable people? We're already seeing the positive results of the NIL bills, as predicted.

We're also seeing direct increased graduation rates of athletes. A poor student whose family needs $20K, can stay in college and earn that money. Before NIL, that kid would have had to leave college early to enter the draft to earn anything. They wouldn't have graduated, and they would have earned millions less.

@mekkaokereke
(1) Can you explain more about what "graduation halo" means? I can only guess.
(2) I THINK The United Negro College Fund talks about the unexpected-expenditure issue. Are they or the Urban League worthy of donations? (I know it's not a structural change.)
(3) (Not a question.) The Atlantic did a big cover story on college sports a few years ago. I didn't read it, but I know it's pretty bad: https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2011/10/the-shame-of-college-sports/308643/ (Ta-Nehisi Coates followup: https://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2011/10/the-shame-of-the-ncaa/246775/)
The Scandal of NCAA College Sports

A leading civil-rights historian makes the case for paying college athletes—and reveals how a spate of lawsuits working their way through the courts could destroy the NCAA.

The Atlantic

@tarheel 1) "Graduation Halo" refers to this phenomenon:

Consider an extended family of 50 Black folk in Mississippi. About 8 family units of cousins, nieces, etc, ranging in age from 2 years old to 84. Each family has the average income for a Black family in Mississippi. Five of the 50 relatives are currently enrolled in college. Each student has ~40% chance of graduating.

Now imagine one family member signs with the NY Knicks. All 5 college kids' probability of graduating just went up.🤯

@tarheel 2) Yes, the UNCF fund is great to donate to, as are other rainy day funds.

I will never bash any short term workaround for the issue facing poor Black families.👍🏿

We can do both. We can help Black families that are poor keep their kids enrolled in college, and we can reduce the racism that transfers money away from those Black families and makes it poor in the first place.