I should share that I was an advisor briefly to Post.news, asked to put together an advisory board. I withdrew for various reasons -- disagreement about another advisor and about federation -- and have no ties to it now. I received nothing. I like Noam, its founder, and respect his work (Waze!). I'll watch Post. But I'm much more engaged here and want to study and learn about the potential of federation -- ActivityPub, Bluesky, Scuttlebutt -- as a model for public discourse.
@jeffjarvis
It's deeply frustrating watching my friends who ought to know better—journalists, tech policy people, etc.—acknowledging that Twitter's on the outs, but then getting excited about moving to yet another closed, proprietary platform.

@arossp @jeffjarvis I don’t say this to be mean, but if your biggest problem with all this is that people aren’t using the tools the way you wosh they would, you’re as clueless to what made Twitter great as Musk still is.

It’s people - & that will remain so for whatever comes next.

If people are finding their communities wherever, that’s great. Most aren’t thinking about open/closed/propritary, etc.

That said…

@arossp @jeffjarvis Mastodon, like all short socials, has its own issues.

And some of the biggest issues remain people.

Even with tech that allows federation, the communities that are developing on different platforms now won’t interact in the same way as they did on pre-Elon Twitter.

Whch means none of them will be quite as diverse or successful as before…

@arossp @jeffjarvis For now, given the rapid speed with which Musk is destroying the old Twitter, I’m glad that people are finding their people wherever.

That’s the most important thing - salvaging the communities & relationships. The tech sh**? That’ll work itself out, eventually. Always does.

You cut out & silence people & communities? Many times, they don’t come back.
-30-