Unlisted posts:

1. Your followers see them
2. They’re public on your profile
3. Anyone can link to them
4. Others can boost them
5. They show up in lists

They do not:

* Show up in the local feed
* Show up in the federated feed
* Show up when searching hashtags

Unlisted posts seem like a great way to post without cluttering the local/federated feeds.

1/3

@ramsey unlisted posts won't show up in hashtag searches though, right?
@ellotheth @ramsey Yeah, this is one design choice I find baffling. Why would I put hashtags in my unlisted post if I didn't want it to show up in hashtag searches?

@lunasspecto @ramsey as always seems to be the case with #masto UX, there's some interesting discussion from back in the day:

Okay so like. Unlisted means "does not appear in public timelines". A hashtag timeline is a public timeline. I think we're pretty clear on this. Use case:

Talk about #followfriday without interrupting real #followfriday toots.

Unlisted public statuses should appear in hashtag timelines · Issue #5463 · mastodon/mastodon

Hashtags in public unlisted toots are processed, but the current implementation of hashtag timelines only displays public (not unlisted) toots, just as unfiltered local and public timelines. While ...

GitHub

@lunasspecto @ramsey oh yeah and a couple comments later, the origin of the warning we have now:

I don't fundamentally disagree with that, but it's not explained anywhere in Mastodon and it's quite confusing. I think the following things should be done to limit that confusion:

  • Display a short warning whenever a #hashtag is written down in the toot text area and the privacy setting for the toot is “unlisted”
Unlisted public statuses should appear in hashtag timelines · Issue #5463 · mastodon/mastodon

Hashtags in public unlisted toots are processed, but the current implementation of hashtag timelines only displays public (not unlisted) toots, just as unfiltered local and public timelines. While ...

GitHub

@ellotheth @ramsey Maybe it's just me but I would use # FollowFriday or #/FollowFriday if I wanted to talk about a hashtag without getting into the searches.

I would like to use hashtags in unlisted posts so I can do mildly self-promotional stuff without showing up in the Federated and Local timelines, though. But it seems unlikely to change now after people have had a few years to get used to it

@lunasspecto @ramsey i don't know, there's recent activity on that issue! all kinds of "settled" design decisions are getting dredged back up again with the influx.
@ellotheth @lunasspecto Do hashtags in your own unlisted posts show up when searching?
@ramsey @lunasspecto maybe if you've got the elasticSearch thing turned on?
@ellotheth @ramsey I mean, I can text search my own posts / favorites / boosts on this instance. But my own unlisted posts don't show up in the hashtags specifically, even if I get there by clicking the hashtag in my post