Hello everyone, thanks to those of you who followed me as I migrated my old Mastodon account (of several years!) from mastodon.xyz to scholar.social. There is a really great community here but I'm moving over to a new account:

@konrad

If Mastodon's wonderful migrate feature works smoothly I think many (most? all?) followers will get transferred over or have otion to. All my old toots stay safely on the frozen account here. I’ll post reasons below. 1/

#instancemigration

2/3 Instance hosts all have difficult decisions on moderation, an important way to make Mastodon a welcome and safe space. They can fully “block” or de-federate bad actors entirely or block media.

They can also "silence" or limit interaction. As I understand this allows you to follow people and read their toots, but crucially removes them from search results when you search for a hashtag. There may be some good reasons for this.

Attached are images that show the admin view:

3/ One reason to "silence" an instance is that, though it has lots of great people, it has poor moderation, and you might not want its hashtag or federated feed from coming into your own instance.

However, it appears that scholar.social decided to "silence" 7 out of the top 20 Mastodon instances. These include: mastodon.online, mastodon.sdf.org, mastodon.social, mastodon.cloud, and fosstodon.org

I see their toots in my home feed, but if I search for a hashtag mentioned, I get nothing.

4/ Because lots of people I would like to interact with (and have turn up in hashtag searches), I decided to move. I applied and was accepted at social.coop. It is not for everyone, but here is what I like: 1) they don't seem to silence major instnaces 2) after probation period, you are expected to pay monthly $1-10 to help upkeep of server, so it is sustainable 3) it has wonderfully thoughout and democratic governance structure.
5/ The Mastodon instance migration procedure: 1) export follows from here and import them over at social.coop 2) leave a goodbye message here so frozen account has informative last message 3) follow the instruction steps for migration feature in Mastodon settings 5) Watch as your old followers trickle in on new server, but last time I did this it was 100% - my guess is that followers get some kind of choice of whether to transfer? What do you see on your end?

@konrad There was nothing to do at my end. It's all automatic. You now show up on my following list at the top (as my most recent follower), as if I newly followed you at social.coop, and your old scholar.social account is no longer on the list.

Thanks for the explanation—there’s lots to learn about a federated universe of social media platforms. I like the way folks are experimenting with different moderation and governance models. Good luck with the move!

@consequently thanks for this! Useful to see how things look from your perspective! As you say great that there is this flexibility and decentralized control. 十人十色 as they say in Japanese! Ten people ten colors! To each their own!
@konrad I must clarify I’m *not* telling anyone to migrate or where to migrate! Sorry if I gave that impression! I was just recording my own process as I experienced it!