i went back to the beginning on this again!
got a free game and the VN itch bundle (i know, i know, no more games) and also reorganized the list a little bit to remove sequels and DLC that i'm not going to play until i get to the first game, so now i'll be able to click right through the list
so i went back to the top with half an hour of aer memories of old:
it was pretty and vaguely soothing, the flying took me a bit to get the hang of but once i got it i had fun. none of the puzzles seemed particularly new or interesting but i really appreciated that the "fly through these hoops and a door opens" puzzle wasn't timed. love the story-through-exploration thing but the number of floating islands actually made the world feel a bit empty - i kept landing on islands and realizing there was nothing there besides a few rocks and maybe a tree. if you're between this and "a short hike" i would say go with a short hike but free is a great price and i had fun with the bit of it that i played