Alright folks -- Do you have questions about how historians think and make claims about the past? Ask away. #MastodonThread #Thread #history
@audreytruschke How would you validate the authenticity of a historical text?

@allen_menezes First step is to make sure that the text was written when it claims to have been and by whom it claims to have been.

One might look at manuscript evidence, internal linguistic evidence (anachronistic language can indicate forgeries), whether the dates add up, contemporary references, consistency with known sources.

Once you establish a text is real, meaning it's from the time period/context it claims, it is another matter whether it is accurate on specific information.

@audreytruschke @allen_menezes I was sent these screenshots on a Twitter DM. Are these authentic?
https://mastodon.social/@AbdurrahmanHussain/103127462094796659
@audreytruschke @allen_menezes Some of the spellings seem wrong, making me think they are forgeries? He says this is because "many of these documents predate Samuel Johnson and Noah Webster and were written at a time when English spelling had not yet been standardised." But I want your opinion, since you've written a book on Aurangzeb.