"No one should do X without first having experience doing X" is a fun fallacy.

For example, asking for five years of experience for an entry-level job.

Or, just off the top of my head, "No one should moderate a social media website if they don't have experience moderating a social media website."

You know, while I'm on the subject of moderation, if you come to a place where one of the draws is "the moderators are human beings and not faceless representatives of a corporate monolith" and then you keep treating the moderators like faceless representatives of a corporate monolith, you're probably part of the problem, not the solution.