bsmall2Apr 18, 2025

> You "have organized your lives around inhuman values," he said. These values
> are inhuman because they cannot be universalized. The system rests on a few using the majority of the resources, while the majority can't even cover their basic necessities. It is crucial to define a system of values and a norm of living that takes into account every human being.

https://znetwork.org/wp-content/uploads/zbooks/htdocs/chomsky/dd/dd-c07-s14.html#FN69

#IgnacioEllacuria #NoamChomsky on #DeterringDemocracy in #ElSalvador #uspol

Show threadBrian SmallJun 27, 2023

.> ... it is more gratifying to bask in praise for courageously protesting the abuses of official enemies, a fine activity, but not the priority of a value-oriented intellectual who takes the responsibilities of that stance seriously.
.> The victims within our domains, unlike those in enemy states, are not merely ignored and quickly forgotten, but are also cynically insulted. One striking illustration came a few weeks after the murder of the Latin American intellectuals in El Salvador. Vaclav Havel visited Washington and addressed a joint session of Congress. Before his enraptured audience, Havel lauded the “defenders of freedom” in Washington who “understood the responsibility that flowed from” being “the most powerful nation on earth”—crucially, their responsibility for the brutal assassination of his Salvadoran counterparts shortly before.
.> The liberal intellectual class was enthralled by his presentation. Havel reminds us that “we live in a romantic age,” Anthony Lewis gushed. Other prominent liberal commentators reveled in Havel’s “idealism, his irony, his humanity,” as he “preached a difficult doctrine of individual responsibility” while Congress “obviously ached with respect” for his genius and integrity; and asked why America lacks intellectuals so profound, who “elevate morality over self-interest” in this way, praising us for the tortured and mutilated corpses that litter the countries that we have left in misery. We need not tarry on what the reaction would have been had Father Ellacuría, the most prominent of the murdered Jesuit intellectuals, spoken such words at the Duma after elite forces armed and trained by the Soviet Union assassinated Havel and half a dozen of his associates—a performance that is inconceivable. - https://www.bostonreview.net/articles/noam-chomsky-responsibility-of-intellectuals-redux/

#NoamChomsky comparing #VaclavHavel with #Ellacuría, #IgnacioEllacuria, #FatherEllacuría to place the #LiberalIntellectualClass in context... #ElSalvador #LatinAmericanIntellectuals #JesuitIntellectuals #USACongress #TheDuma

The Responsibility of Intellectuals, Redux

Using privilege to challenge the state.

Boston Review
Brian SmallJun 27, 2023

.> I don’t mean to equate a Vietnamese villager to Vaclav Havel. For one thing, I doubt that the former would have had the supreme hypocrisy and audacity to clothe his praise for the defenders of freedom with gushing about responsibility for the human race. It’s also unnecessary to point out to the half a dozen or so sane people who remain that in comparison to the conditions imposed by US tyranny and violence, East Europe under Russian rule was practically a paradise. Furthermore, one can easily understand why an oppressed Third World victim would have little access to any information (or would care little about anything) beyond the narrow struggle for survival against a terrorist superpower and its clients. And the Pravda hack, unlike his US clones, would have faced a harsh response if he told the obvious truths. So by every conceivable standard, the performance of Havel, Congress, the media, and (we may safely predict, without what will soon appear) the Western intellectual community at large are on a moral and intellectual level that is vastly below that of Third World peasants and Stalinist hacks — not an unusual discovery. - https://chomsky.info/19900301/

#NoamChomsky in a letter to #AlexanderCockburn writes about #VaclavHavel and #ElSalvador, how #TheColdWar #TheInvasionOfVietnam and #JesuitPriests like #IgnacioEllacuria expose the level of #WesternIntellectuals to be that of #StalinistHacks...

On Vaclav Havel Speech

The Noam Chomsky Website.

Show threadBrian SmallFeb 23, 2023

.> Father Ignacio Ellacuria, rector of the Jesuit University before he was assassinated along with Father Martin-Baro, described El Salvador as "a lacerated reality, almost mortally wounded." He was a close associate of Archbishop Romero and was with him when the Archbishop wrote to President Carter, pleading in vain for the withdrawal of aid from the junta. The Archbishop informed Father Ellacuria that his letter was prompted "by the new concept of special warfare, which consists in murderously eliminating every endeavor of the popular organizations under the allegation of Communism or terrorism . . ." Special warfare---whether called counterinsurgency, or low-intensity conflict, or some other euphemism----is simply international terrorism-and it has long been official US policy, a weapon in the arsenal used for the larger sociopolitical project. - Excerpt from Deterring Democracy (1992)
#Carter #JimmyCarter #PresidentCarter #OscarRomero #ArchBishopRomero #IgnacioEllacuria #Ellacuria #ElSalvador #SpecialWarfare #InternationalTerrorism #Terrorism #SocioPoliticalProject
@bsmall2

Democracy in the Industrial Societies; Force and Opinion; Afterward, by Noam Chomsky (Excerpted from Deterring Democracy)

The Noam Chomsky Website.

bs2Apr 27, 2022

"[You] have organized your lives around inhuman values, [these values] are inhuman because they cannot be universalized. The system rests on a few using the majority of the resources, while the majority can’t even cover their basic necessities. It is crucial to define a system of values and a norm of living that takes into account every human being."
https://chomsky.info/199011__/

#NoamChomsky #Ellacuria #IgnacioEllacuria #TheWest #Inhumanvalues #Universalized #CatholicChurch preview of #LaudatoSi

The Victors

The Noam Chomsky Website.