After the Republican midterm disappointments of 2022,
Peter Thiel called for a party that could unite “the priest, the general, and the millionaire”
— a formula that reads, with hindsight, as a precise blueprint for Trump’s second administration:
Christian nationalism, military force deployed at home and abroad, and a financial oligarchy powerful enough to steer the state.
By the election of 2024, the gospel of nostalgia and the gospel of progress had concluded a short-term bargain to elect Trump.
The result is the rise of an oligarchy of fewer than 20 American families.
The first clear sign that the promise of the digital commons had curdled came with Edward Snowden’s disclosures in 2013,
when Americans learned that Google and Facebook had opened their back doors to the security state.
What had been marketed as an architecture of connection revealed itself also as an infrastructure of monitoring.
By the mid-2020s, the fear had hardened into habit.
A 2025 YouGov survey found that nearly a quarter of Americans admitted to censoring their own posts or messages for fear of being watched or doxxed.
Surveillance no longer needed a knock at the door.
The mere awareness of a watching eye did the work.
What had been a public square had become, almost imperceptibly,
a panopticon of self-restraint.
Into this apparatus stepped a new class of private overseers.
Palantir, the data-mining firm Thiel co-founded, grew from a counterterrorism instrument into a generalized engine for correlating personal information
— tax filings, social media traces, the bureaucratic exhaust of ordinary life.
Insiders warned that data citizens had surrendered to the IRS or Social Security for basic governance could be recombined for far more intrusive purposes.
The point was not simply that we were being watched,
but that we were being rendered legible
— sorted, scored, and classified in ways invisible to us.
As Anthropic’s CEO Dario Amodei told The New York Times,
the Fourth Amendment’s prohibition on unreasonable search and seizure is effectively nullified by AI:
https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/political-commentary/rise-digital-oligarchy-ai-era-1235534437/