Lilian Edwards

3K Followers
570 Following
3.2K Posts
Emerita Prof of Law, Innovation Society at Newcastle Law School; Hon Prof Glasgow/ CREATe; AI, DP, intermediaries, genAI. Founder #gikii, ILAWS , (co) SCRIPT, CREATE. Ex Turing/ ATI. Wild ( livid?) swimmer. #intro #introduction #bio website ( needs updated) [email protected], @[email protected]
Websitehttps://www.lilianedwards.co.uk/
University sitehttps://www.ncl.ac.uk/law/people/profile/lilianedwards.html
Wikipediahttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lilian_Edwards
PronounsShe/her

Pleased to note my Cambridge lecture on how technical approaches to the right of explanation have gone haywire in the LLM era, is already up!

I discuss the spread of legal mandates of explanations of algorithmic decisions but at same time increasing unreliability of explanations offered by "reasoning" LLMs. Chain of Thought not = explainability!!

Many thanks to @CIPIL who um may not be here? And to @jennifercobbe for her v kind invitation!

https://youtu.be/wLxuq3I2d_s?si=h8vfHGaLhB7it3hG

Faithful or Traitor? The Right of Explanation in a Generative AI World: CIPIL Evening Seminar

YouTube

Not only can #preprints be cited, citations to preprints are growing. Using the literature on #AI policy for a case study, these authors found that citations of preprints increased 8x over the last decade, from 5% to 40%.
https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.16477

#Citations #Impact #ScholComm

Shifting 'AI Policy' Preprints and Citation Trends in the U.S., U.K and E.U., and South Korea (2015-2024)

This study of literature focusing on 'AI Policy' over the past decade, found that citations of preprints, publications on platforms such as arXiv, have increased from five percent to forty percent across three major regions: the U.S., U.K. & E.U., and South Korea. We compare regional responses of preprint citations across the global disruptions of COVID-19 and the release of ChatGPT. We discuss driving factors and risks of preprint normalization, which follows the trend in computer science.

arXiv.org

The NHS Ten Year Plan states: "One study found AI helped improve performance of highly skilled workers by 40%, in certain tasks achievable by AI, compared to those who didn’t use it"

The study it cites tested management consultants advising CEOs on stuff like developing product and marketing strategies and producing reports on market segments. "ChatGPT lets management consultants do their job more efficiently" is perhaps not generalisable to other professions and fields.

📰 "A Norwegian man said he was horrified to discover that ChatGPT outputs had falsely accused him of murdering his own children."

Ars Technica on our second complaint against OpenAI 👇

https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2025/03/chatgpt-falsely-claimed-a-dad-murdered-his-own-kids-complaint-says/

Dad demands OpenAI delete ChatGPT’s false claim that he murdered his kids

Blocking outputs isn’t enough; dad wants OpenAI to delete the false information.

Ars Technica
Research for the European Commission on social media use and loneliness - DHOMBRES, B., KOVACIC, M., SCHNEPF, S.V. and BLASKÓ, Z., Loneliness and social media use in the European Union, European Commission, 2024, JRC135806
From the abstract: "Spending more than 2 hours per day on social network sites is associated with a substantial increase in the prevalence of loneliness. Intense passive use of social media is also linked with increased loneliness. ...." [1/2]
The Balanced Economy Project's submission to the AI and copyright Consultation:
https://static1.squarespace.com/static/65c9daef199ea70aa66592fe/t/67c6ddb73070d877b6700ea6/1741086136179/UK+AI+Submission_250225.pdf
In its newsletter BEP says "The UK’s creative industry has an impressive track record in contributing to national income, is a pioneer on the global stage, and enriches culture and society. Generative-AI is yet to prove itself as a positive force for public good. For a government that wants “growth at all costs”, the UK creative industry is a surer bet than an untested generative AI industry."
SWGfL (which runs amongst other things the Revenge Porn Helpline in the UK) has published a news release trying to estimate the scale of NCII. It is not cheery reading- their figures suggest that in the UK women equivalent in number to the population of Birmingham experience NCII each year (and for the US they estimate a group equivalent to the population of Louisiana). It seems to be more prevalent than CSAM.
https://swgfl.org.uk/magazine/the-scale-of-non-consensual-intimate-image-ncii-abuse-a-data-driven-global-analysis/
The Scale of Non-Consensual Intimate Image (NCII) Abuse: A Data-Driven Global Analysis

Our findings highlight that NCII affects an estimated 1.42% of adult women annually in the UK, read our full report.

@cstross I'm sure you're aware of the current issue of Private Eye.
Boost if you want less generative AI in your tech in 2025.
For what it might be worth a letter has been written. TL;DR - Let the CMA and DMU do their goddam job and reign in big tech to help UK economy. Can’t blame the Grauniad for the mis-spell... https://www.theguardian.com/business/2025/feb/06/tech-firms-publishers-which-magazine-raise-fears-new-boss-competition-regulator-doug-gurr
Tech firms, publishers and Which? raise fears over new boss at competition regulator

Exclusive: Appointment of ex-Amazon UK boss prompts group letter to chancellor airing fears over approach to big tech

The Guardian